In past uploads I may have mentioned that I like to listen to covers, be them true in nature to the original or of differentiating interpretations. The internet provides such a wealth of musical talent beyond originals and covers. Isolations and analyses of compositions are features of which I particularly enjoy.
One person that I follow is Rick Beato, who as part of his Everything Music channel, has a series called “What Makes This Song Great?” In it, he breaks down song structures that will cause you to never hear the song (that you know and love) in the same way again. His ear can pick out the subtleties that, if not part of the song, would not sound the way it does.
Beato is a musician, an engineer, a producer and a teacher. Well versed in many musical instruments, he brings his expertise to the masses purely for the sake of the music. Besides Rick’s WMTSG series, he has other videos within his channel will present and teach theory, structure, harmony, etc. He really gets “in the weeds” when it comes to his presentations.
His latest upload is an analysis of arguably one of the greatest rock songs of all time: Comfortably Numb by Pink Floyd. It is the last song on the third side of the double album released by the band in 1979. The music is by David Gilmour with lyrics by Roger Waters. While among the greatest of rock songs, the adulated stature is gained by perhaps one (two) of the greatest guitar solos within a rock ballad.
Beato’s enthusiasm, as he breaks down the song, will allow the listener to also hear the much finer points of very minute nuances of instruments that might not be evident on the record. He elaborates these in such a way that it brings out isolations which make up a vital part of the composition. His mannerisms add to the enjoyable pleasure of the parts even if the techniques and vernacular are above the comprehension of a non-musician.
For your consideration:
What Makes This Song Great?, Episode 104, Pink Floyd, Comfortably Numb:
For reference, as if anyone needs it, this is the original:
Comfortably Numb- Pink Floyd
If you enjoy the WMTSG concept, here are some other notable break-down analyses by Rick
Episode 81, Stevie Wonder- Superstition
Episode 19, RUSH- Closer to the Heart
Episode 36, YES- Roundabout