One time, I got some NY strips that were so good, that I spent years trying to repeat it. I'm sure I missed some good steaks during that time. For my current favorite, I'll stick with Frank. Nothing like a porterhouse. They are awesome!
NY Strip all day long for me. I like the ore meat flavor that i get on a strip as opposed to a ribeye. Honestly though, i like all the cuts and they all taste good
James; you can't go wrong with a bone in rib eye! I'm sure no matter what you decide to grill, your girlfriend will soon know what a great cook you are! Enjoy.
I also forgot the why part. The marbling and bone give a deep beef flavor that can't be beat! Plus,puppy boy gets REAL excited when he sees that bone coming his way!