I'm with you on that Bryan, I think you should only need one thermocouple. Reason being, the thermocouple is only a requirement for high heat cooks, and the leads on the probes (and thermocouples) can't handle being inside the grill during high heat cooks, so when doing high heat cooks you end up using just the pit probe. The other reason I wanted a thermocouple is because high heat cooking and MOISTURE kills even the High Heat Maverick probes pretty rapidly, however, I have had a Thermoworks Pro probe outside all summer and it's still good as new! WAY more weather resistant than the Maverick probes. I know some people say they had problems with the Thermoworks probes, but mine have always worked great on every version of the HM that I have built, and they have been the most resilient probes I have bought, the only time I have killed one is when I took them way over their rated heat range...