Sorry to gang up on so many of you at one time, but here it goes;
Jim; thanks for posting your dims, looks like your charcoal area is a little larger. I am extremely interested to hear what kind of temps and times you can attain with your design. I can get the kettle to hover in good about 260 for 7.5 hours with no touching.
RL; (everyone else don't read this) Sometimes I have trouble getting foil from the box too, especially when someone pushes those tabs in cause they think they are showing me something cool and new... I hate them, it makes the roll, well, not roll so well in the box.
The metal will naturally come and go, because one side of the plate is warmer than the other side. It will gradually deform more and more, and will be worse with thicker material because it will not flex back so easily. I still think 11Ga (0.1196) is better than 14Ga (0.0747"). In my situation, I had the side fully loaded with lit coals, the lid off, and vents wide open below. I probably had 700°+ on one side of the plate, and maybe 100° on the other side. This caused very minor warping, if it wasn't a new shiny toy, I wouldn't be concerned at all. Actually, another bend at the top of the vertical piece would be a better alternative, but not a cure.
I see no reason why plain carbon steel can't be used. Stainless was available to me, so I used it. Just keep the carbon seasoned and dry, and it should be ok.
Albert; Send that 26 3/4 to me and I get you all set
Albert & Tom; The tapers on my insert are straight, I don't think that little bit of airflow will change the results at all. The point is to keep the cool air from mixing with the warm air causing drafts, the insert funnels (for a lack of better words) the cool air through the hot coals to MINIMIZE the drafts. No big deal to me; but yes, Jim's looks better than mine. Just remember, bricks aren't usually round either
Jim;
"Leakage is a non-factor"
If that rum was leaking from your lip... does it then become a factor?
This has really become a fun project for me, thanks for posting the idea Jim.