Well, it looks like the reaction to the new Limited Edition Red Kettle may be short of what Weber and retailers were hoping for. I saw on the Weber Kettle Club site and confirmed by my own attempt that you can now get one of these for $149 at Home Depot, a drop of $50!
This price at least puts it in line with the Premium Kettle Grill with which is more comparable instead
of the nicer Master Touch. So, maybe you can find one with no chips and have a new Red a Kettle just in time for Christmas!
My honest feeling is that the current kettles, and I'm talking about a Performer that is a couple years old compared to a 30 year old kettle, are just not the same.
The newer kettles just don't have the same steel, I tried to measure it and it seems that the newer kettles are about .010" thinner than the older ones. The lid is obviously one of the parts that is damaged with dents which get rusted. There are some dents on the 2 year old kettle I bought used recently. Also, the vent holes are punched though and leave lips around the holes, where the old lid had a flush rim where the vent hole was punched through.
Then I noticed today at OSH that every single kettle on display had dented edges on the lids.
In reading this thread on the "Limited Edition", it really exhibits the exact same issues. Dented rims on the lids, which even start to rust...I have to believe that Weber just doesn't make kettles the way they did 30 years ago, and I have one to compare side-by-side with a Performer Deluxe prior to the GBS inclusion.
Also, it is sure nice to have the handle on the vent, must easier to open/close, but it's so flimsy compared to my 30 year old kettle vent, it's very noticeable. You can see the rivet is already starting to pull away and loosen up on the newer one, and you can lift the vent off the lid pretty easily, as I said it's very flimsy where the 30 year old vent rivet is rock solid, similar to how it was shipped 30 years ago. The paint is obviously ore durable on the 30 year old kettle, and I have thrown it around on the dirt, the patio, the table, etc...but it has held up fine. I scratch my head as the Performer I just got will not last or look the same in 30 years.
My lid is actually in better shape and doesn't have any dents in the edge, and no rust spots like the newer one. Ok, I could blame the previous owner, but he took darn good care of the kettle, and it was cleaned when I bought it. Grill is in XLNT shape, half a bottle of gas for the starter, and even has a cover...these dents and rust spots on the edge of the lid are typical of what is seen on the floor models at OSH.
The proof is in the pudding. I'll add some pics to show these details to my thread when I have some time tomorrow.