Neither one, I have mine.Which part are you looking for? The pan or the wire cage?
I like hearing opinions and advice, thank you all that respondedIt looks the same except under close personal inspection which it won't get underneath your grill, and since it won't see any use, why not?
That's why I prefer the aftermarket ones, for the more original looking black tray. If I have a nice original porcelain one I will purchase the Weber kit and just not use the aluminum tray. I have a few of those in my garage, they do come in handy for putting screws and bolts in when I take apart a grill.I agree with Steve.
You can tell the porcelain ones by the finish and also because they were a heavier gauge metal than any black painted ones you will find. You probably can still find one of those, but not likely in brand new condition. For just a "display" grill you could just buy one of the new painted black thin ones. It looks the same except under close personal inspection which it won't get underneath your grill, and since it won't see any use, why not?