First time cooking pork butt on WSM


 
J

JohnTex

New member
Hi guys,

This upcoming weekend is looking good. No wind and 35-40 degrees. Cold, I know. But thats how it is in Scandinavia!

I intend to follow the pork butt slathered mustard rub recipe found in the cooking topics.

Since I only will be cooking one and with a weight of 4,2 pounds (trimmed) I was wondering how long you guys think the cook will take (approximately)?

All the best from Denmark
Jonathan
 
I’m guessing you are speaking about Celsius not Fahrenheit?
i suppose it doesn’t REALLY matter that much with little wind, once you get to a stable temperature, (250-275 F) you can find yourself rolling along just fine and then hit a stall, that will send things sideways if you don’t think about it. I’ve been surprised more than once. “Normally” I’d figure an hour to an hour and a half a pound but, (that could be a big but but, not a big Butt sorry, bad butt humor) start earlier than you even hope it will take, I’ve become a serious fan of the LONG rest on the back side of the cook, up to four hours wrapped in a towel and tucked away in a cooler while everything else is prepared, arranged, made pretty and guests get plenty of cocktails?
OK, not back to your simple question, start with at least 5 hours cooking time and a couple of hours resting time.
At least that’s what I would do.
Enjoy the cook!
 
JohnTex said:
I intend to follow the pork butt slathered mustard rub recipe found in the cooking topics.
Click to expand...
That states 225-250.
JohnTex said:
Since I only will be cooking one and with a weight of 4,2 pounds (trimmed) I was wondering how long you guys think the cook will take (approximately)?
Click to expand...
Hard to be right on, but usually 1.5 to 2 hrs per Lb at those temps.
Raise the temps, lower the cook time, easy peasy.
OBTW welcome to the board!
 
Timothy F. Lewis said:
I’m guessing you are speaking about Celsius not Fahrenheit?
i suppose it doesn’t REALLY matter that much with little wind, once you get to a stable temperature, (250-275 F) you can find yourself rolling along just fine and then hit a stall, that will send things sideways if you don’t think about it. I’ve been surprised more than once. “Normally” I’d figure an hour to an hour and a half a pound but, (that could be a big but but, not a big Butt sorry, bad butt humor) start earlier than you even hope it will take, I’ve become a serious fan of the LONG rest on the back side of the cook, up to four hours wrapped in a towel and tucked away in a cooler while everything else is prepared, arranged, made pretty and guests get plenty of cocktails?
OK, not back to your simple question, start with at least 5 hours cooking time and a couple of hours resting time.
At least that’s what I would do.
Enjoy the cook!
Click to expand...
Hi Timothy,

Thanks for the reply. I actually mean fahrenheit! :-)

Sounds like a plan with the 5 hour cook and resting time.

All the best
Jonathan
 
If I were cooking that pork butt again from the Cooking Topics article, I'd do it at 275*F. I pretty much do all of my low & slow barbecue at that temp these days.

www.virtualweberbullet.com

Pork Butt - Slathered With Mustard & Rub - The Virtual Weber Bullet

Pork butt slathered with yellow mustard, then rubbed and smoked to tender perfection in the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker. Serve as a sandwich or slider.
www.virtualweberbullet.com www.virtualweberbullet.com
 
Chris Allingham said:
If I were cooking that pork butt again from the Cooking Topics article, I'd do it at 275*F. I pretty much do all of my low & slow barbecue at that temp these days.

www.virtualweberbullet.com

Pork Butt - Slathered With Mustard & Rub - The Virtual Weber Bullet

Pork butt slathered with yellow mustard, then rubbed and smoked to tender perfection in the Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker. Serve as a sandwich or slider.
www.virtualweberbullet.com www.virtualweberbullet.com
Click to expand...
Hi Chris,
Thank you. I will try it at 275*F. What would your guess be on cooking time when total weight is 4 lbs?

All the best
Jonathan
 
OK, thanks for that clarification on CvF scale. I’d still plan on 6+ hours cooking plus another hour minimum rest. Like I said, I’ve become a huge fan of the longer rest and have started striving for the three to four hour rest and am very pleased when I can get that. At that ambient temperature I agree with Chris, go 275. Better to have the butt reach internal temp early rather than late.
I suppose that’s the long way of saying set aside nine to ten hours.
 
JohnTex said:
I will try it at 275*F. What would your guess be on cooking time when total weight is 4 lbs?
Click to expand...
I've never smoked one that small. Usually 8 hours for an 8 pound one at 275*F. Not sure it's half the time for half the weight, but I guess I'd plan on 4 hours and see how the internal temp goes.
 
I've done many that small around 240-260F. I put it in by 8 am. At around 1:00-2:00 in the afternoon It's normally 160-165 internal. I wrap mine when 165F so I take if off about 1.5-2 hrs later when it's 205F or tender. I let rest for 1 hour still in foil in a towel and immediately pull it for dinner.

Depending on the initial internal temperature it may get to 160 a bit earlier but I like to let it sit at the stall for a bit. Mine are usually frozen and put in the fridge to thaw out a couple days in advance. Sometimes it's still pretty icy when I start.

When they are this small I'll usually cook two. On my 14.5 WSM I put one on each rack.
 
Last edited:
Good luck on your cook.
Our area gets chilly too.
When it recently hit the low 50’s we considered that balmy weather.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

 

Back
Top