Corned beef Cured two ways - Side by side comparison


 

CaseT

TVWBB Platinum Member
My wife and I spent the weekend down at the Oregon Coast. We had a great time. Weather was crap but we had a few nice breaks and we had some excellent beach strolling.

One day we visited an Irish pub. We both had several half and half beers and lunch. Honestly can say I had one of the best bought burgers I've ever had.

While drinking those beers and eating that fantastic burger, my wife the one who remembers everything, reminded me that I was making corned beef for Saint Patrick's day. Not just any corned beef, homemade cured corn beef.

Oh crap! What day is it? When are we getting home? Phew just enough time to make it work!

Fast forward. After work I stopped at Cash and Carry. It's our restaurant supply. Brisket $2.60/#, Angus Brisket $2.64/#. I splurged and got the Angus, better be good!

I decided in another thread that I'd separate the flat and point and cure them two different ways.

33177639041_b56f0729c3_c.jpg


The point I am going to cure in Pop's brine.

http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/110799/pops6927s-wet-curing-brine

The flat I am going to cure by dry brine curing, using Martins "Digging Dog Farms" cure calculator

http://diggingdogfarm.com/page2.html

I have used both these methods for corned beef, pastrami, bacon, etc. I have not done a side by side comparison of the two methods for corned beef.
Please note the final product will not be smoked so no pastrami. This is plain old corned beef.
Most will be dismayed at the amount of fat I trimmed off this brisket. I like my corned beef lean not fatty.

32922907850_48e6d99f26_c.jpg


Here's the flat all trimmed:

32462775184_7f36c99a47_c.jpg


Here's the point:

33305686345_88a50b4307_c.jpg


Okay lets talk cure! I was going to make my own pickling spice but I was out of four of the spices needed so I bought premade, which has everything I was going to use anyways and was $20 less than buying all the bulk id need to make my own.

33264923056_db13d30ddf_c.jpg


*Not pictured white sugar. It I is in a container that doesn't represent what it is.

Both methods use Salt, sugar, and Cure #1. Pop's also uses brown sugar.

Pops' Method


http://www.smokingmeatforums.com/t/110799/pops6927s-wet-curing-brine

33177628051_c4e884fdc5_c.jpg


I decided that 1 gallon wasn't going to be enough brine so I mixed up 2 full gallons.
I started by putting 1 gallon of water into a pot on the stove. I added all of the dry ingredients per Pop's recipe x2, except the cure, into the pot. I didn't have cheese cloth to put the pickling spice into so I modified one of my homemade muslin sausage bags and added 1 cup of pickling spice to it.

2/3 cups salt
2 cups granulated sugar
2 cups brown sugar
2 heaping tablespoons cure #1 (do not add to hot liquid)

I brought this to allow boil over medium-high heat, then reduced to a low simmer and let that roll for 30 minutes. Turned the heat off and allowed the brine to steep and cool slowly.
Once cooled Down This gets added to the brine bucket with another gallon of cold water. If you are in a hurry you can also use ice in place of water. I wasn't so I just used cold tap water.
Once the temp dropped to 50 degrees I added the 2 tablespoons of cure. You could inject at this stage, but I felt that the thickness didn't warrant the effort.

Dry Brine Method using Martin's "Digging Farm Universal Cure Calculator".

http://diggingdogfarm.com/page2.html

Flat weighed in @ 2601 grams

Per the Calculator here's what we nee for the rub:

32462757344_9557bc5d4a_c.jpg


Mix all that up. Rub half on one side of the flat. Rub the other side with the other half of the mix.
I ground up the pickling spice for the aromatic rub. I applied this by eye to every surface of the flat.

32491110953_bd9e2eb0a3_c.jpg


32462763284_b014f4b6d7_c.jpg


33177608071_00ddf4596c_c.jpg


Vacuum sealed and ready to cure. I will flip and massage this once day until it is time to cook.

About the Cook

Sous vide it is. Probably around 36 hours and a temp around 133-140. Still reading and will continue to read until I have to cook.

The results will be in my next post!
 
Here's how it went. After curing for 14 days I puled the point from the brine and vac packed it. Fired up my Anova wifi sous vide cooker and cooked both the flat and point for 10 hours @ 183°. The results were fantastic. Everyone agreed that the flat was the best corned beef they'd ever had. I have to agree, dry rub curing is my favorite method. The point was tasty, just not as tasty as the flat. Both had perfect texture. Not mushy, not fall apart crumbly, but melt in your mouth awesomeness.

32791771303_c47fb1ba08_c.jpg


33448928972_6cc73ef8b4_c.jpg


Served for Saint Patricks day with cabbage, onions, taters.

Left overs included these:

Homemade sauerkraut, Russian dressing, swiss

33448927482_728d78aea4_c.jpg


33448925442_4432437897_c.jpg


Corned beef hash made with leftover point, cabbage and onions. The eggs are from our neighbors chickens. These are really tiny, taekes 3-4 to make a large store bought. Almost as small as quail eggs!

33565019186_7b8181fa31_c.jpg


33448897252_61042771a7_c.jpg


33476577771_e881dd4106_c.jpg


Next one I do I will smoke and turn into pastrami!
 
Wow! Thanks for documenting your side-by-side on these two methods. I'm working on a plan for some home-cured pastrami using a dry cure, smoke, then sous vide, so this gives me some good inspiration. Looks like both methods turned out great!

Rich
 
Wow! Thanks for documenting your side-by-side on these two methods. I'm working on a plan for some home-cured pastrami using a dry cure, smoke, then sous vide, so this gives me some good inspiration. Looks like both methods turned out great!

Rich

Thank you Rich! Yes both turned out great. The dry rub edged out the brine though.

- - - Updated - - -

Wow Case,Your posts and details are about the best I've ever seen and read.,.. Great job bro.

Thank you James.
 
What an informative post Case. Love the detail and information you provided. I recognize the work you put into sharing this with us. I'm bookmarking this one. Your results look fantastic. Excellent photos as well.
 
What an informative post Case. Love the detail and information you provided. I recognize the work you put into sharing this with us. I'm bookmarking this one. Your results look fantastic. Excellent photos as well.

Thank you Cliff!

The dry cure is my favorite way to cure meat.

Makes the best texture and the flavor is much better than brine cured.

For the cook, this Sous Vide attempt was my best to date. I've had mixed results. This was perfect.
 
Man Case you nailed that one for sure. It all looks so delicious and I want some. That hash pic looks so yummy, you really out did yourself on this one.
 
My sister and I did many parish dinners at St. Patricks here in Kalamazoo for the patronal festival. She did the rub using the "Cooks Illustrated" recipe from probably twenty years ago, best flavor ever!
Eight days under rub, 2 cauldrons of simmering water, about twenty five pounds of beef in each pot, six hours simmering, one bottle of Bushmills seriously damaged while setting up for dinner for 70! Suffice to say, a good time was had by all!
Sadly when she and I announced that we were unable to continue the job, no one stepped up to learn how. Now it's nowhere near the Bacchanal it once was.
 
Thanks Case, you always post the most informative posts on TVWBB, and this is no exception..Corn beef heaven right there.
 
Wow what a lesson on the fine are of curing. I must admit most of it was over my head but the food pics looked beautiful. I must google this sous vide stuff that I see all the time but have no idea what it is. That Reuben sandwich is killer! And the hash! Oh my! You are very talented. Your cooking and methods are really top notch. Great job!
 
Got to agree with Barb, you nailed it and a lesson in curing corned beef on top of it.

Thanks Case, you always post the most informative posts on TVWBB, and this is no exception..Corn beef heaven right there.

Wow what a lesson on the fine are of curing. I must admit most of it was over my head but the food pics looked beautiful. I must google this sous vide stuff that I see all the time but have no idea what it is. That Reuben sandwich is killer! And the hash! Oh my! You are very talented. Your cooking and methods are really top notch. Great job!

Thank you! Hopefully this post will get some into home curing. For corned beef and pastrami it's the only way to go!
 

 

Back
Top