Problem with your opinion is one is actually a Comercial grade cooker and the other is an expensive big box store toy compared to it, yet people act like they wouldn't want it.
Here is what I find extremely challenging in your opinion. If both sat side by side and you could only have 1, I doubt very seriously you would choose the weber, and I have no affiliation, like I actually see a weber guy that chimes in time to time. That's fine, but I don't buy much of his storyline. He's trying to sell people here or he wouldn't be here. You can't literally spend 2k on a weber now that doesn't hold a candle. That's my point, and why I posted it to you in the first place. It met everything you said you would want.
It's OK to say something is better then a weber, and still keep your head above water. People that become so entrenched in a product line is amusing. The auto makers all have good, bad, and just pure junk. Some fanboys will never admit it, and some will buy whatever the emblem is, and eill most likely be much happier. I bought weber, because it was either that or some random China made 50 buck special.
Grills are the same, and now that more weber is China made the less I care about them. That's just the truth for me. They could easily still be 100% usa made, and I don't care what some weber sales guy says. They do it to max out their earnings plane and simple. There's a margin of gain, and then there's just being greedy. IMO they made bad calculated moves, first being moving production for greed second, having too many different models, and tried to reinvent the wheel vs greasing them. They have always been more expensive so the reason to go cheap, just hurt them way more then staying well built vs their competition, and still being more expensive. Better, and expensive is a good scenario vs As good at best, and more expensive.
Just look at how much SNS can sell a kettle for vs what weber does. How many options would a weber fan love to have, that SNS has added? They're small in the market, yet can still be very competitive and cheaper with more options. They have less buying power and far less marketing and buy in power to retailers. Weber should be head, and shoulders better.