I think you need to definitely try the new Genesis and decide for yourself. I had a Silver A for 18+ years and loved it. However, I have a new S-345 that I love more. The new grill is not made as solidly as the old, but seems solid enough. It probably won’t last as long for sure. However, I like the way it cooks better. It gets hotter, faster, works better for 2 zone cooking, etc. I don’t spin things on a gasser, but that would definitely be where the older grills beat the new with their east west burners.