Okay, first thank for all the words of wisdom. It really does help hearing from people in the know when you are new to something.
I just got back from seeing the $150 grill. It was cherry. I know I said I was going to go with $75 one, but this thing was a such a peach I couldn't pass.
It was super clean, inside and out. Not a spot of rust. And did I mention clean. Fired it up and it was hot, hot, hot within a matter of minutes. The pictures that where on Craigslist didn't do it justice. Even the Weber emblem on the front looks amazing.
The only thing this one really need are some new flavorizer bars, and a quick wipe down, and it's good to go. The grates need to be wiped down, but they are in grate (pun intended) shape. Plus I have a set of 5 Grillgrates that I bought for the old Costco grill to try and get a little more life out of it. The Grillgrates are amazing by the way. I have been using a couple of them on the Kettle, and will throw the other ones on the Genesis.
I ended up getting it for $125, and it was in such great shape, and such better shape than the $75 one, that I feel like the $50 was totally worth it. This guy really took great care of this grill. It's actually been sitting in climate controlled storage for awhile, which I'm sure attributed to the condition.
Anyway. Thanks again. I'll post a couple pics as soon as I get it out of the truck.