• Enter the TVWB 27th Anniversary Prize Drawing for a chance to win a Weber Traveler Portable Gas Grill! Click here to enter!

The revenge of the Brisket and my rant


 

Rich Dahl

R.I.P. 7/21/2024
Let’s start out by saying I’ve done about 20+ cooks on my mini and have been impressed by its performance. Its rock steady, wind, no wind, hot, cold whatever. I would say with the butts, ribs, meat loafs, turkey breast, PSB I’ve done almost all have been great.
So I thought I would try a little three pound brisket flat for fun seeing that I have never done one before. My expectations weren’t too high from reading the posts on the forum as it seems the flats are pretty difficult to get right
.
I fired up the mini as I always do minion and a few chunks of hickory for this cook. Got it settled in at 260 and put the flat on. The temp dropped to 250 and stayed there. Ten minuets later I look at the maverick and its reading 190, okay open the bottom vent a little and ten minuets later its 325. Let the games begin! Now I’m chasing temps, never did this before. After an hour or more I finally get it stable at 270, good enough.

Then I hit the stall at 151 and it sits and sits for 2 1/2 hours on a three pound flat!
Thought the mav had gone south on me, nope the thermopop read the same thing when I checked. Finally at 5:30 we hit 165 and foiled it.

Started at 12:30 pm and it’s now 6:30 and the flat is at 190 and as tender as a chunk of flagstone. Barb is heating leftover spaghetti for dinner and I’m trying to get enough booze in me to make this reality go away.
7:30 the mini is out of fuel and the flat is 207 and seems to have the resistance not of butter but of wet concrete off it comes and will let it sit wrapped in a towel for an hour or so then into the fridge and tomorrow we’ll take a look.

Now if you’ll excuse me I’m going to have another dance with Mr. J. Daniels.

If it came out decent I’ll post how I did it tomorrow.

briskit002_zps19bc08d4.jpg

briskit010_zps2d0caeec.jpg
 
Thanks for the rant. It's definitely a love/hate relationship. I've ruined more than my fair share of briskets, but when it comes out right, it's golden. I think it's a bit like golf, where one or two great shots help you forget about the ones that fell in the sand, water, rough, and trees.
 
it's still undercooked, right? I've not done one that small yet, but you just haven't hit the window yet. After it's overcooked it'll dry out but be tender... right? Throw it in the oven while you're drinking away your sorrows!

>>>edit - did you foil it? I think the braising process is most important when you're dealing with less fatty cuts.
 
Hang in there Rich and keep on plugging away. At least it was a small cook. Could have been a 14 pounder with eight hungry people waiting to eat! You'll nail he next one!
 
it's still undercooked, right? I've not done one that small yet, but you just haven't hit the window yet. After it's overcooked it'll dry out but be tender... right? Throw it in the oven while you're drinking away your sorrows!

>>>edit - did you foil it? I think the braising process is most important when you're dealing with less fatty cuts.

Yep, foiled at 165.
 
Tricky little cuts heh my friend. Had many a JD night over tough cooks. I bet you pop it open and find a decent meal sitting there for you.
 
Edit to add,
I did not post pics of my flat cook to brag. I've messed up too much meat to do that.:rolleyes:
Rather, it's for those who say never cook just the flat, or never cook a small flat.
It can be done.

Rich,
I'm sure that brisky will be eaten, one way or the other.

I often cut part of the flat off a whole packer and have two cooks that way.
This piece was cooked on my 18" WSM, no pan, nothing but fire down below.
IMGP9260.JPG


IMGP9268.JPG


It was great.
 
Last edited:
The point of foiling to me is to force whatever your cooking through the stall. I would have foiled it when you noticed the stall start.
 
I'm sorry Rich, I have nothing to add, other than it's all a learning experience, and thank goodness consolation comes in an (affordable) bottle :)
 
Rich it happens to the best of us! It is more than likely nothing that you did, just a bad piece of meat. I have had my share of them trust me!
 

 

Back
Top