Here is what he wrote today on his FB group. I personally don't have any thoughts one way or another aside from feeling he's the one whom needs to make decisions about design and manufacturing processes based on his volume and market conditions. I would guess he would not make changes that would result in an inferior product experience:
Folks we had a lot of questions yesterday and I know change is always treated like it's... change. I think it's important to get the facts in one location. Here they are:
I have spent 3 years trying to improve the design of the original Slow 'N Sear, reduce cost, and improve our capacity to manufacture.
Over the last 3 years our costs have continually gone UP though we have kept the price the same.
The Slow 'N Sear 2.0 offers the following improvements:
- 20% more water capacity in the reservoir
- 30% more sear zone with the reservoir removed
- Reduced ash buildup in the charcoal basket due to an improved bottom plate pattern
- Reduced warping due to overbored rivet assembly that allows for flex during high heat cooks
We did make a change to 430 SS, which is a bit cheaper than 304 SS, however, we use the SAME GAUGE of metal, which is what's most critical. Both metals have the same coefficient of expansion when heated and similar melting point. 430 SS actually melts at a little higher temp.
The new Slow 'N Sear has the same 10 year warranty as the old Slow 'N Sear and is made of MUCH higher quality material than the porcelain enamelled carbon steel lid and bowl of your kettle. The SnS metal is not the weak link in this equation.
The new design is better and with time I'm confident you're going to love it as much as I do.