@Brett-EDH - thank you so much for posting this thread recently. I saw this thread at the same that I was thinking about making lamb for the very first time. It seemed achievable (as opposed to some of your other feasts which are way out of my league), and you made some great notes for success. Between this and talking about the sear option on my pellet grill with some other members recently, I took the plunge today. Unfortunately, no one else in my house likes lamb, so I did it today while the kids were at school and my wife was at work. Not a bad way to spend my lunch while working from home.
Wasn't cheap, but I got $5 off the package at Costco a couple of weeks ago:
View attachment 69743
View attachment 69749
Seasoned it with SPG&RM. Set the pellet grill at 300 and let it cook until IT of 100 (about 20 minutes), then pulled it off and let it rest for about 5 minutes while I increased the set temp and opened up the searing grate over the burn pot. IT rose to about 107 before I put it back on the grill.
View attachment 69750
View attachment 69751
View attachment 69752
I was getting a bit more variation on my IT than I was expecting when testing with my instant read. It was somewhere between 124-138, depending on where I poked it. I was expecting it to be overcooked, but it was just about perfect for me. I know some people like it more rare, but this is about where I wanted it, so I got really lucky.
View attachment 69756
View attachment 69757
View attachment 69753
Couple of notes for next time. For some reason, I totally didn't see that you wrapped the bones in foil. Now I can see why. I also overseasoned it a little bit. I don't think I was getting the full taste of the lamb through the salt, so I'd back off a little bit next time.
Sorry for hijacking your thread, but I had to give you props for helping me do this. It was an absolutely amazing meal that I will try again when I'm home alone and it's a nice day. Thank you!