I was not at all agreeing with his presentation, and I do admit it wouldn't take a whole lot to clean it up more. But, like Bruce says, if someone chooses to do just the bare minimum and has happy paying customers, what can you say? And, sadly, I do think that the return on every additional hour spent on a grill like that becomes less and less.
The one factor that this short-term perspective does not take into account is customer loyalty and referrals. While satisfied to get what they wanted at a price they were OK with, I doubt anyone who would buy that grill would be that excited to brag to their friends about their purchase or the "restorer." On the other hand,
@Bruce is getting repeat customers and people standing in line because of his sterling reputation that prior buyers DO share. I know that from talking with him recently, but I am sure that this is true of a number of others here on TVWBB who take a great deal of pride in their workmanship. Doing the minimum is a job. Making an old grill a gem is a joy.