No grease under the coals with my FireDial -- which I love.
Most of the drips hit the hot metal. Most vaporizes (just like a flavorizer bar on your gas grill). Some gets through the slots down to the coals -- which then burns up like on a charcoal grill, UDS or a WSM running hot/fast with no pan at all. I haven't touched them, but the FD comes with adjustable flaps which would let more heat/smoke/drips go between the top and bottom of the smoker.
I will use a foil drip pan on the FD on occasion if I want to collect drippings for gravy/sauce or want to add a little bit of moisture to the cooker.
On the 18, one really nice thing the FD (or a pizza pan) does is free up some space around the charcoal chamber. With that overly deep water pan in the 18, it is pretty cramped when tending the coals or adding wood.
I haven't tried it, but people seem to like the Hunsaker plate too.