Mine arrived today and, while I don’t care for or condone the deceptive practices, the product is acceptable. Acceptable doesn’t mean without flaws, though. The weight seems right on point and the rolled lips and holes are right in line with OEM. The porcelain leaves something to be desired, however. Both of mine arrived with a chip in the same underside corner of the tray and the porcelain is identifiable as quite thin as a result. There are also some waves that are visible in the flat surfaces of the porcelain as well. All things considered, these trays serve their purpose and fill a hole in the market so I will keep them rather than return them. At the same time, I’ll probably blacklist BBQparts.com for anything that I can source elsewhere due to the shenanigans here.