You might be better off coming up with a different solution, as those holes are massive and I'd hate for you to ruin your WSM. I'm seriously doubting you can find a stepbit that size but if you do, that's the way to go. Only other option is probably a metal hole saw attachment for a drill (it's just a type of bit). Standard spade bits would never work.
Have you considered going with something smaller and fitting a readily available grommet? The stock/OEM grommet is actually quite wasteful on space. They could've probably gotten away with a hole 1/2 the size of the current one, as the only functional areas on the grommet are the 2 slits in the dead-center, and those don't need much space to slip an entire probe through.
Many folks like myself (with my old 18") take a cutting/grinding wheel from an angle grinder and cut a small slit at the top of the middle section, where the inner lip begins horizontally (ie you dont cut the vertical portion, just the lip/ring part the lid sits down on). You can then run probes easily through the gap, while also keeping it pretty sealed up.