Second Smoke: Pork Butt - Comments and pics


 

Elie

New member
Everyone,
My second smoke is DONE! and it was a 5.5lb pork shoulder (boneless) with lump charcoal. Overall it was a success.
Below, please find comments and so feel free to criticise and offer directions.
1- I asked the butcher to tie the butt for me, and he used this mesh net around it. I do not think it is a good idea... since it might have limited the bark.
2- Last week for my first Rib trial, I had a hard time lighting up the chimney. Following a suggestion here, I bought these Weber starters and this it started like a charm. Thank you.
3- I rubbed the pork, and put it on at 7 am. With overall temperature going between 225 and 250, I pulled it out at 230pm with a reading of 190 on my Maverick. I left it, as people suggest, in a cooler for 2 hours, wrapped in foil.
4- Overall, I thought it could have used another half hour: there were pockets of pure fat inside that would have rendered.
6- I did not open the lid at all, which might have been a mistake. I thought the outside could use more ``color.''
7- The inside, was good, but some pockets were drier than others (and harder to "pull"). I am not sure that would improve with longer smoking.
8- The bark could have been a bit thicker and darker... that is how I remember it last time I had this.
9- One issue is that I light up the smoker with sort of the minion method, but with charcoal. So, I load it up extra. Today, after 7+ hours without touching it, I still had more than 1/3 of the charcoal in the chamber unused... I wonder whether it is a weather issue (it was 85 deg here all day...). But, I was surprised that it lasted this long (btw, also the water pan was still 1/3 full).


Conclusion: We were spoiled last week with the baby backs which I personally prefer. But, there were pieces that I ate while pulling it (fatty with bark...) that I thought I was daydreaming. The flavor was just perfect. Perfect.

As always, thanks for everything. Next up: brisket.

Here is a picture of the finished product:

https://www.dropbox.com/s/wnskqd9eq95yiqa/2013-08-24 15.40.07.jpg

Finished product
:)
https://www.dropbox.com/s/6kh8un43s8iis7s/2013-08-24 16.00.19.jpg
 
It sure looks good. Nice job for a first time. Make notes so you can remember what you liked and didn't like to refer back to on your next attempt.

One suggestion: Once you come to your desired temp take the temp in a few different places. This may help with those pockets you found. Make sure it's all where you want it.
 
1) I typically use bone-in butts, but when I use boneless - I don't worry about tying them up. Just plop them on the grate and carry on. :)
2) Glad to hear the lighter cubes treated you right.
3) 190 is a starting point to check for doneness. Using a probe (skewer, thermometer, etc) insert it into the butt and see is there's resistance. If there is, keep on cooking until its knife-through-butter tender.
4) There will be pockets that don't render out. As you're pulling, just grab them and discard.
5) You skipped #5. :D
6) Not opening the lid is the right thing to do.
7) Some of the tougher parts will tenderize with longer cooking.
8) Sugar makes for a nicer bark, IMO. I'll add brown sugar during the last couple of hours.
9) Having 1/3 unused charcoal after 7+ hours is very normal. That's what makes the WSM so great!

conclusion : you're hooked! Welcome to the club.
 
In no particular order:

I always use bone-in too, more to maintain the form of the butt.

I agree 190 is too low. I always shoot for 195 min to 200. That's just about another hour or so. The cooler is a good idea if you want to hold the meat. I typically will do 2 to 4 butts at a time, and a cooler can hold them for a long time before pulling. However, if you are going to pull one right away, just put it in a 1/2 sized aluminum pan, and just tent some foil over the top and let it set for 30 minutes.

I don't use water, so I will always begin spritzing once an hour after the bark sets. Mind you, I don't remove the cover, but more tip it up enough to spray an Apple Juice concoction quickly on all of the butts. There is very little heat loss this way, and the DX2 gets it right back to temp very quickly this way.
 
I pull my pork butt off the smoker when it hits 195-200.
I trim a lot of the fat off and leave very little to get better bark.

Keep cooking and try different methods and see which one you like the best.
 

 

Back
Top