Salad dressing recipes?


 
After looking at the ingredients on a bottle of ever-more-expensive salad dressing, and being shocked at the crap they put in that stuff, I think it's time I made my own.

Of course I'm going to make the ubiquitous ranch & thousand island varieties (which are about the only thing my wife will use), but I'm also looking for more interesting options.

The only requirement (or limitation, if you prefer) is that they can't be terribly hot; my wife won't eat spicy foods, so jalapenos (and anything hotter) are out.

What have you made that you liked?
 
we don't do creamy dressings. we prefer these:


have made a few of them over the years. note, if you're going to fridge any dressing, the EVOO will solidify and require going back to room temp before using. so we'll use a heat treated olive oil as the base oil, or make the vinegar part of the dressing and make a small batch with EVOO for any particular meal. this way you get the health benefit of EVOO, and it's flavor, without the coagulating of the oil from the fridge.

when making fruit dressing, raspberry specifically, i'll buy raspberry jam and use that for the fruit part and then add in vinegars, SPOG/herbs/whatevs, so as to make the balance of sweet and acidic (ACV, WV, Champagne vinegar, Wine vinegar).

when using dried herbs, as in Italian dressing, making it a day in advance will allow for the herbs to hydrate. and we do use dried minced garlic too in dressings, again they need hydration.

what's nice about making your own is you can control the sugar amounts and use better oils versus canola, which is a pretty crappy oil IMOO. we don't buy or use Canola.

Some good oils we do use are heat treated OO, safflower, EVOO, infused EVOO (think garlic and or with rosemary), Avo and on a very rare occasion, corn and more rarely, soybean (another bad choice, IMOO).
 
+1 for vinaigrette
Although I like more vinegar than the classic proportion

Another one is yoghurt with garlic, some pepper & salt and maybe a little lemon juice or vinegat

And a Thai dressing of fish sauce, lime juice or vinegar, chili (you can leave out or reduce) and garlic (optional)

More Chinese: sesame oil, soy and lemon juice or vinegar

Many many options :)
 
note, if you're going to fridge any dressing, the EVOO will solidify and require going back to room temp before using. so we'll use a heat treated olive oil as the base oil
I'm not familiar with this; a quick google turned up nothing, nor did a search of our local supermarket's online inventory. Where do you get such a product?
 
I'm not familiar with this; a quick google turned up nothing, nor did a search of our local supermarket's online inventory. Where do you get such a product?
Costco sells an olive oil that can be used for frying. So does just about every market. It’s just not EVOO. Any light colored olive oil, not sold in a dark bottle, will be processed so it can be used to fry foods with due to having a higher smoke point and not become bitter when cooked at high temps.


How Does Olive Oil’s Smoke Point Compare to Other Cooking Oils?​

As mentioned above, extra virgin olive oil generally has a smoke point of 350⁰F to 410⁰F. The reason EVOO has a smoke point range as opposed to a specific number is that smoke point depends on an oil’s free fatty acid (FFA) level, according to the North American Olive Oil Association. The FFA content of extra virgin olive oil ranges from 0.2% to 0.8%. Higher quality EVOOs often have lower acidity and thus a higher smoke point. Regular olive oil, which is a blend of virgin and refined olive oils, generally has a smoke point around 470⁰F, but may be more prone to oxidative damage due to its lower polyphenol content.

Here are the generally accepted smoke points of most common cooking oils on the market:

  • Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 350-410⁰ F (possibly higher with high-quality EVOO)
  • Regular or Light Olive Oil: 470⁰ F
  • Virgin Avocado Oil: 375⁰ F
  • Refined Avocado Oil: 520⁰ F
  • Virgin Coconut Oil: 350⁰ F
  • Refined Coconut Oil: 450⁰ F
  • Butter: 300-350⁰ F
  • Ghee or Clarified Butter: 450⁰ F
  • Corn Oil, Sunflower Oil, Safflower Oil: 450⁰ F
  • Unrefined Sesame Oil: 350⁰ F
  • Refined Sesame Oil: 410⁰ F
  • Canola Oil: 400⁰ F
  • Grapeseed Oil: 400⁰ F
  • Unrefined Walnut Oil: 320F
  • Unrefined Peanut Oil: 320⁰ F
This explains how oil is made for the different kinds of olive oil you can buy.


“While the initial olive milling process may be similar (although temperatures in the processing might be cranked up to improve extraction), the steps in creating refined olive oil are quite different. They involve using substances like alkali, activated carbon and high heat or steam to rid the olive oil of any flaws in flavor and aroma. Olive oil that didn't make the cut as “extra virgin” or “virgin,” i.e. lampante oil, is used to make refined olive oil.”

Basically, EVOO becomes firm at fridge temps which makes it undesirable in a cold salad dressing. Using a light olive oil or just non-EVOO, the oil will remain fluid if put in the fridge which makes for a decent oil to use if making a large batch dressing to keep and store.

I will often just make a quick room temp dressing for salads and not keep fridged versions. It’s very easy to make a quick dressing that has much more flavor than retail products and that are healthier too, as in less sugar and clean ingredients.

SPG, EVOO and lemon or lime juice (fresh squeezed) is a main goto for us. Sometimes I’ll add a pinch of sugar to round it out flavor wise.

If you have a stick blender, you can whip up an excellent vinaigrette in no time. Even using a hand whisk works well too.
 
Last edited:
We use Good Season's Italian or Garlic package mix. You use your own oil and vinegar, so we use good EVOO and good Balsamic vinegar.
 
My first from-scratch salad dressing was this Honey Miso recipe from back in 2010:


Verdict: very good! I might add just a touch more honey to better balance the acidity of the vinegar and the saltiness of the soy sauce, but it's quite nice as written. It will definitely have a place in my rotation.
 
Last edited:
My second try was this recipe for "authentic" Thousand Island:

I omitted the bell pepper, as my wife's digestive system doesn't tolerate it well.

Verdict: I really don't like Thousand Island dressing, but this was very good. In fact, I couldn't get enough of it! Not as much of a vinegar tang as with typical bottled dressings, but a very creamy taste instead. It's a real winner in my book, but more importantly my wife liked it.

I'm also working on a vinaigrette, and a bit of an unusual one. More on that later; I have a lot of these two dressings to eat up first!
 
Grant, I bumped up a couple of recipes from the "Side Dish" site. There might be more there, didn't check them all.
 
we don't do creamy dressings. we prefer these:


have made a few of them over the years. note, if you're going to fridge any dressing, the EVOO will solidify and require going back to room temp before using. so we'll use a heat treated olive oil as the base oil, or make the vinegar part of the dressing and make a small batch with EVOO for any particular meal. this way you get the health benefit of EVOO, and it's flavor, without the coagulating of the oil from the fridge.

when making fruit dressing, raspberry specifically, i'll buy raspberry jam and use that for the fruit part and then add in vinegars, SPOG/herbs/whatevs, so as to make the balance of sweet and acidic (ACV, WV, Champagne vinegar, Wine vinegar).
I took one of the recipes from your link and experimented a bit to make an elderberry vinaigrette. We have elderberry trees on our property, and my wife makes elderberry jelly from them every year, which I've put to use in this recipe:

3 parts rice vinegar
3 parts elderberry jelly
2 parts light olive oil

It's addictively delicious! Just the right balance of sweet/tart.
 
Creamy Dill Dressing

1/3 C (75g) High Quality Mayonnaise I use Duke's or Best Foods/Hellman
1 Tbs Apple Cider Vinegar
2 tsp Lemon Juice
2 tsp Garlic minced, about 2 medium cloves
2 tsp Fresh Dill, chopped
1/2 tsp Fine Sea Salt
Fresh Ground Pepper to taste
Mix all ingredients in a small bowl and refrigerate for at least an hour.
 
I took one of the recipes from your link and experimented a bit to make an elderberry vinaigrette. We have elderberry trees on our property, and my wife makes elderberry jelly from them every year, which I've put to use in this recipe:

3 parts rice vinegar
3 parts elderberry jelly
2 parts light olive oil

It's addictively delicious! Just the right balance of sweet/tart.
That looks great! Any “interesting“ jelly might be fun, elderberry is not something I tend to have on hand, black currant is more likely. At least, for me.
Looks like something with a fair amount of latitude for flavors.
I just noticed the 1000 island notation you made about bell pepper. My wife is not able to tolerate green pepper at all but, yellow, red, or orange don’t have any bad side effects. I understand the discomfort some folks have with green pepper. Not fun for them at all!
 
Last edited:

 

Back
Top