Wow I just finished a 7.5 lb butt on my 14.5 and I ended up getting 16 hours of burn-time from one load of Kingsford Long-Burning charcoal (heat shield removed and I'm sure the 100+ degree heat index helped on that burn-time). Still needed another 2 hours in the oven to get to probe tender. Resting in a cooler now.
My first cook on my 14.5 WSM was this 11lb butt. It barely fit and took 14 hours to fully cook but was delicious. Probably would've been done in 12 but I wasn't paying attention at one point and let the smoker get down to 185 degrees before refueling.
225-250, did not wrap. No clue why this one took so long but glad I started the night before.That is a long time in the smoker, Danny. What was your average temp?
That is a long time in the smoker, Danny. What was your average temp?
Welcome to the forum, Matt.![]()