Nobody liked my leg of lamb


 
Closing any vent will decrease temps, not increase as the increased airflow creates hotter temps. As far as the marinate goes, I see no issues with putting it on while still wet. My guess is closing that top vent some created the creosote that was already mentioned which will be a bitter taste for sure.

I agree with this assessment. I think that it also didn't help that charcoal was added. I think there was a multiplier effect here.

Sorry to hear about the cook. I know how bad it is to do all that work and not have it come out well. With a nice piece of meat, it can also be expensive. Better luck next time.
 
I guess I would first like to ask if you have ever had smoked lamb that you liked?

Both my wife and myself like lamb and eat it regularly, however, neither one of us ever thought that smoked lamb even sounded all that appealing. Lamb is obviously a natural for grilling, and we know it curries very well. In fact, one thing perfect about lamb is how well it absorbs flavors from a curry. Much better than chicken, beef or pork. I would guess that it might also absorb smoke flavor at a faster rate and thus be a bit on the smokier side if treated like poultry or other meats that are routinely smoked.

We can eat smoked ribs, brisket and pork until it comes out of our ears. (Personally, I am a bit tired of smoked turkey...) but lamb...I just don't know. As I said, I've never had smoked lamb but it doesn't jump out at me as a natural.

So in the end, I am just wondering whether it was your technique or smoked lamb, in general, that your guest reviewed. ( In any event, I'll probably give smoking lamb a try in the near future just to see if I am missing something.)
 
Tasted smokey, did have the top vent half closed for a time to try to bring up temps. Also took the leg out the maranade and placed on the grill while still wet. Is that wrong?


It's a learning process. Leave the top vent open in the future. I control temp with the bottom vents.
You said you closed the top vent to increase temp. This is the opposite of what should have happened.
Fire needs fuel and air. When you choke the air, you reduce the thermal potential of the fire. Open up all the vents to increase air. Add a small fan to one of the bottom vents if you are really having troubles....

BBQ is all about learning...or is it an obsession??!
 

 

Back
Top