I've tried all three. I thought the bourbon one was ok, but I'm just not big on whiskey sauces. I think whiskey is better for drinking! I think the mustard is the best of the three, although it's a little on the sweet side. I'd prefer it more mustardy if that make sense, but it's a good sauce. The hawaii one is pretty good, and didn't come across as too sweet for me. I with you on that Carolina Vinegar sauce. I didn't find it at all representative of a Carolina sauce, but I love it on just about anything.