I'm thinking something to with the spring loaded vent. I asked about the dial numbers and the temps by the position of pics I sent him. Here was his reply.
"Here is my easiest answer. forget the numbers they are just there as a reference. The damper moves a degree angular for every 1+ degree C (or F) that the temperature changes. So if the damper is set at 90 degrees on your kitchen counter, it will take about 130 degrees more heat to close the damper completely and cool the grill. If you want 200 degree grill- start with the damper about 90, if you want it about 220 start it at about 110degree angular. There is a 15 degree temp swing and a several minute delay as the coals and device work against each other.
I have had it as low as about 175 and holding and as high as 250 and holding. But at high heat the device is pointless unless you like leather.
Also remember that the damper moves INDEPENDENT of the knob, so if you turn it to a number after it is warm, that is not the same value as room temp.
From your pics, 1 is closed of course, 2 would be about 180-190, 3 about 220-230 and 4 maybe 250.
Depends on the ambient temp when they are set, and everything relies on a good air seal.