Sam Anthony
New member
Fired up my new (used) WSM 18.5 for the first time today. The cook went pretty well and here are some pics. Questions follow at the end. 
Running at 275-285 for most of the cook. Nice sunny day here in Georgia!
About halfway or so through I lifted the lid to baste on some more Mojo Sauce. Took just over two hours and about 3 beers to get the meat to about 165F.
Plated and ready to chow! Great smoke flavor but almost overwhelming. Some Mojo flavor but the Hickory was a bit much.
Notice in the second pic the wings toward the front were cooking much faster than the ones in the back. My guess is the door is not sealing as there was a bunch of smoke coming through the door?
I used two chunks of hickory (about fist sized) for the cook and the smoke died down about an 1.5 hrs in the cook. The smoke flavor was nice but overwhelmed all the other flavors. Maybe I should have marinated a bit longer than the 3 hours I let it sit in the Mojo? Use only one chunk next time?
I crisped the skin on the grill for a couple minutes before serving. The skin bit through and had a nice crunch to it. The meat was juicy on most of the pieces except the ones toward the front on the top rack. Meat temps on the top rack was 165-168 with a few toward the front being 170. The bottom rack didn't have the same color (lighter) and was a bit lower temp at 163-166. I let the bottom rack go for about 15 more minutes while I crisped the wings on the grill from the top rack.
Pretty pleased overall with the meal. The family enjoyed it and I had a blast just sitting outside, jamming with some tunes, drinking a few Stella Artois Belgian Lagers and watching the smoke swirl in the breeze.

Running at 275-285 for most of the cook. Nice sunny day here in Georgia!

About halfway or so through I lifted the lid to baste on some more Mojo Sauce. Took just over two hours and about 3 beers to get the meat to about 165F.


Plated and ready to chow! Great smoke flavor but almost overwhelming. Some Mojo flavor but the Hickory was a bit much.

Notice in the second pic the wings toward the front were cooking much faster than the ones in the back. My guess is the door is not sealing as there was a bunch of smoke coming through the door?
I used two chunks of hickory (about fist sized) for the cook and the smoke died down about an 1.5 hrs in the cook. The smoke flavor was nice but overwhelmed all the other flavors. Maybe I should have marinated a bit longer than the 3 hours I let it sit in the Mojo? Use only one chunk next time?
I crisped the skin on the grill for a couple minutes before serving. The skin bit through and had a nice crunch to it. The meat was juicy on most of the pieces except the ones toward the front on the top rack. Meat temps on the top rack was 165-168 with a few toward the front being 170. The bottom rack didn't have the same color (lighter) and was a bit lower temp at 163-166. I let the bottom rack go for about 15 more minutes while I crisped the wings on the grill from the top rack.
Pretty pleased overall with the meal. The family enjoyed it and I had a blast just sitting outside, jamming with some tunes, drinking a few Stella Artois Belgian Lagers and watching the smoke swirl in the breeze.

Last edited: