Curveball: butt AND shoulder


 

Mary M

TVWBB Fan
Need some timing and other help! I'm cooking for a party next Saturday for my dojo. One of my dojo buddies raises pigs, and he offered a couple of butts. Woohoo! Fabulous backyard pork! So exciting!

So today he gave me the meat, which is one nicely trimmed boneless rolled butt (about 5 pounds) and an untrimmed bone in picnic.

Suddenly...method and timing are a lot less straightforward (I think).

I'm planning to trim the skin and fat from the shoulder - if I was making pernil or carnitas I'd leave it on, but it doesn't seem like a good idea for smoking. The bones stay in because it seems like a bad idea to try to bone it and roll it. What about cooking time? Are they going to be radically different?

To complicate matters, I'm thinking of also doing a brisket over the butts because the amount of pork may be a little light (we're looking at about 30 guests but it could be more), which means the butts will be tricky to get at.

Is this just a big succession of bad ideas? Would I do better to buy another butt to make the nut?
 
Mary,
All I can tell you is what I would do, and that is buy 3 butts about the same weight, and save the boned butt and picnic for later enjoyment.
It would stress me out with 3 different shoulder cuts, and/or a brisket thrown in the mix.
Good luck!
 
Mary,
All I can tell you is what I would do, and that is buy 3 butts about the same weight, and save the boned butt and picnic for later enjoyment.
It would stress me out with 3 different shoulder cuts, and/or a brisket thrown in the mix.
Good luck!

I think if they are similar wt, it wont make any difference.
I cooked/pulled a shoulder, was same to me to cook. But i think the butt makes better pulled pork.
 
Confession time: I did buy a brisket. It was beautiful and decent price. But I think it would be nutty to add it to this cook.
 

 

Back
Top