I have only been to a few whole pig smokes. They all cut the skin, then peel it down to get to the meat. I have never really tasted any smoke in the meat. Are they not doing it right? The meat was really good and tender, but no smoke flavor. Is that normal? I know depending on who I am smoking for, when doing a picnic cut, I will leave the skin on 1 of them for the people that aren't into smoke as much. Cooked skin side down, there isn't as much, if any smoke flavor on that side of the picnic.