Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
If it's good enough for you. It's good enough for me. I trust your judgement and I like to use genuine Weber parts whenever possible.
304 Stainless - Magnetic?
- Thread starter John-NY
- Start date
Steve Hoch
TVWBB Hall of Fame
It's not like you're buying the aftermarket ones for half price so it's not worth it in this case.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
You are absolutely right
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
Very true. The more I think about it I can just leave mine out of my grill 99% of the time. It'll be fine. I'm just trying to build my BBQs with the highest quality parts I can source. I don't mind to pay more for something that will last. The warming rack is not at the importance level as the grates of flavorizer bars though.
Again, in looking at the actual seller of that product (it's not Walmart) the item says "sold and shipped by HNLLC." They are located in, China.
Believe me Josh, I'm of the same mindset, I want good quality 304/316 stainless parts. But the fact is, most of these Chinese companies are playing fast and loose with specs and marketing. I've seen many listings claim the item is "Made in USA", which are actually from China. Caveat emptor.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
Nice catch and good point. I'll just grab the factory Weber ones for 20 bucks maybe a few of them. Can't beat the price yeah it's Chrome plated Steel and not made to last but I don't use them very often I'll just keep it out of my grill unless I need it. The warming rack is nowhere near the importance of my grates and flavorizer bars.
Bob Erdman
TVWBB All-Star
I have that rack, no complaints, paid 49 bucks. Can't stand the plated ones.
Bruce
TVWBB 2-Star Olympian
I know Rivers Edge was one of the few sources for high quality 16ga SS flavorizer bars for the Genesis 1000 grills.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
Cool thanks Bruce!
Yes, it's helpful to get verified experience with the brand... although I'm still not sure what that Walmart vendor (HNLLC) is selling, as their brand is cited as "CMS". Thus I remain leery of the Walmart listing. Upon visiting the actual website for RiversEdge, this particular item ($55) is listed as "out of stock." IMO, I would be inclined to contact and order from them directly to ensure you get the real deal Josh.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
Thanks Scott
I did see that when I looked up the manufacturer.
Also I'm not a fan of Walmart. Just because I haven't had good experiences dealing with them and their customer service and their constant mistakes. Ordering anything from Walmart is a last resort option that I would rather avoid.
AndyK
TVWBB All-Star
I’m a retired steamfitter and engineering contractor that mainly specialized in high purity piping & tubing.
None of my 304 or 316 stainless steel piping was ever magnetic.
Several (read most) of my cooking/bbq items claim to be type 304 but yet magnets stick to them
.
I think we are being hosed when someone asks a manufacturer to go as cheap as possible but still be acceptable.
There are simple corrosive tests but they know no one will ever test their products.
None of my 304 or 316 stainless steel piping was ever magnetic.
Several (read most) of my cooking/bbq items claim to be type 304 but yet magnets stick to them
.I think we are being hosed when someone asks a manufacturer to go as cheap as possible but still be acceptable.
There are simple corrosive tests but they know no one will ever test their products.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
So far my QuliMetal brand 304 SS 9mm grates are not magnetic. I have a very strong magnet and not even a little bit of attraction 
. I can check my Weber #9930 304 SS 3/8 grates when I get home. Also RCplanebuyer custom fab flav bars. I suspect none of them are magnetic.
QuliMetal is not the cheapest but by far not the most expensive. I have purchased multiple grates from them and flav bars and deflectors. I put them in grills I donate or sell. I would recommend them for a decent quality semi budget conscious build.
. I can check my Weber #9930 304 SS 3/8 grates when I get home. Also RCplanebuyer custom fab flav bars. I suspect none of them are magnetic. QuliMetal is not the cheapest but by far not the most expensive. I have purchased multiple grates from them and flav bars and deflectors. I put them in grills I donate or sell. I would recommend them for a decent quality semi budget conscious build.
Steve Hoch
TVWBB Hall of Fame
The set of #9930 grates I have is slightly magnetic. I set a kitchen magnet on one and it just barely holds on.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
Ooh ok. Thanks Steve
That's what I get for assuming
Last edited:
Steve Hoch
TVWBB Hall of Fame
Maybe yours will be different? Personally I don't take that as a lack of quality. They are after all made of steel. If they aren't magnetic at all it just means a higher mixture of non magnetic elements vs. actual steel. I'm no expert on this but my set of grates have held up wonderfully for being 28 years old.
Josh Dekubber
TVWBB Diamond Member
That's all that matters to me! As long as they hold up for the long haul I'm happy.
John-NY
TVWBB Pro
Not to endlessly carry this on, but just figured more data is always helpful, if not at least interesting.
My set of two #9930 that came together, one of them is magnetic, the other is not.
(Red kitchen magnet sticking to one, falling off the other)
My set of three #9930, none of them are magnetic (unless the crud on them is preventing a true test. I haven’t cleaned them yet).
LMichaels
TVWBB 2-Star Olympian
I believe when the welding process takes place some of the properties change slightly. And I think I mentioned this before. If you think about it, you can buy high quality SS pans a magnet may not stick to BUT put that pan on an induction range and it will heat up. If there was 0 magnetic properties, the induction burner would not work