2nd Smoke tomorrow


 

CTobin

New member
So tomorrow I am going for my second smoke ever on my 18.5" WSM. I'm doing a 9lb bone in pork butt I got from my local butcher that I will serve on sunday as pulled pork. I am very excited and nervous at the same time. I was hoping to get some of your opinions. So recipe wise I am between going with amazingribs.com perfect pulled pork and The Renowned Mr. Brown recipe here on this site. What are your opinions on them, or do you have an even better one? Also, what is the best way to reheat the pulled pork?

My first smoke went really well, I did ribs but left them in a bit too long but they were still amazing. I used my maverick 733 and it worked awesome to monitor the internal temperature of the smoker. Compared to the built in gauge, it was 50 degrees off, easily the best purchase so far besides the smoker itself. I decided to use lump charcoal bc it's natural and for some reason I started caring about that sort of thing along with smoking. I found lump charcoal difficult to work with. I had a hard time keeping a steady temperature, is that common with lump? I also must add that for my first the weather conditions were terrible, heavy winds and pouring rain. I'm hoping the weather played a role in it bc I would like to continue using lump. I also found that a lot of the charcoal wasn't getting lit around the outer edges, is that common? What do you guys do when it's time to add more, I know people use tongs to add them but its a pain doing 1-2 pieces at a time. I'm hoping i can get it lit better tomorrow so I won't have to worry about adding more.

Any tips or advice for my first pork butt would be well appreciated. Thanks for the help!
 
I like Mike Mills Magic Dust. http://bbq.about.com/od/rubrecipes/r/bl50617d.htm

I add onion powder or garanulated onion to mine. Same proportion as the garlic.
You can reheat in a crockpot. Save some of the drippings when cooking or use some Apple juice or chicken broth and add it to help keep it most. Stir it up occasionally. Add some of the rub and stir that in to.
 
I've been using Sweet Rub O' Mine lately, and really like it. I like my Q' hot and fresh, so i'm planning on waking up nice and early to do a 10lb butt for Sunday.
 
Lump can be problematic. Since so few coals are actually burning, one needs to pack it in tightly when used for long cooks. Large empty spaces are not your friend.

If you save the pulled pork in a zip lock type of bag or a vacuum seal type, either steaming the bag or reheating by placing in boiling water works well.

Wishing you an Enjoyable cook !
 
Welcome to the site. This is a great place to learn. Here's my 2 cents:

- As far as recipes go, I haven't found one I didn't like yet. I found Harry Soo's method (on this site) came out very well. I also really like the rubs from Oak Ridge BBQ - really good stuff. I use a mix of apple and hickory and my family likes that combination.

- I only use Kingsford briquettes, but as long as you are hitting your temps I wouldn't worry too much about what is lighting and what isn't.

- I had temp problems as well until my smoker got "gunked" up. But from what I've read from others it might be a little extra work to control temps with the lump, but then again I don't use it so advice from others will be more valuable than mine.

- I've had a few burnt fingers and hands while trying to add more charcoal until I found a nice fireplace shovel at a garage sale for a buck. Now I just fire up another chimney (or partial chimney), dump it in my kettle and shovel it into the smoker. Works great for me. No gloves needed and no more burns.

Just my 2 cents. Happy smokin'.

Todd
 
So tomorrow I am going for my second smoke ever on my 18.5" WSM. I'm doing a 9lb bone in pork butt I got from my local butcher that I will serve on sunday as pulled pork. I am very excited and nervous at the same time. I was hoping to get some of your opinions. So recipe wise I am between going with amazingribs.com perfect pulled pork and The Renowned Mr. Brown recipe here on this site. What are your opinions on them, or do you have an even better one? Also, what is the best way to reheat the pulled pork?

My first smoke went really well, I did ribs but left them in a bit too long but they were still amazing. I used my maverick 733 and it worked awesome to monitor the internal temperature of the smoker. Compared to the built in gauge, it was 50 degrees off, easily the best purchase so far besides the smoker itself. I decided to use lump charcoal bc it's natural and for some reason I started caring about that sort of thing along with smoking. I found lump charcoal difficult to work with. I had a hard time keeping a steady temperature, is that common with lump? I also must add that for my first the weather conditions were terrible, heavy winds and pouring rain. I'm hoping the weather played a role in it bc I would like to continue using lump. I also found that a lot of the charcoal wasn't getting lit around the outer edges, is that common? What do you guys do when it's time to add more, I know people use tongs to add them but its a pain doing 1-2 pieces at a time. I'm hoping i can get it lit better tomorrow so I won't have to worry about adding more.

Any tips or advice for my first pork butt would be well appreciated. Thanks for the help!

I guess I would start with an injection. I like the one on this site by Chris Lily, Championship Injection. Any rub that you like should be OK. However, I would foil my butt with a little apple juice after it hits about 160 degrees. There is a fare body of opinion that says foil. I foil and find it really works well.

I wouldn't get too worried about a butt. With injection and foiling, it's pretty hard to screw up. I find that pulling the butt at around 200 degrees and checking to see if I can pull the bone out cleanly let's me know it's ready. At worst it will be good, and best it will be superb. Except for the time investment, butts almost never fail. Good luck and enjoy the meal.
 
The only injection I ever used was the Chris Lily one, but eased back a little on the salt. I only did it once, not because I didn't like it or anything, but I'm fairly lazy by nature. Haha. Since then, I have just let them go with no injection and no foil. Again, it's my own laziness. Still turns out product people rave about.

Regardless of what you do, I think just coming up with a plan and sticking to it is what matters.

Oh, same thing with the rub...I made my own for a while, then saw and tried Famous Dave's pork rub and found that I happened to like the flavor profile. See, lazy. Ha
 

 

Back
Top