Yah, Most I have seen were different. If you have a lathe, I would definitely try to make a set out of the Brazillian Walnut to match the shelves. To me, it looks like they were an afterthought.
Josh, the lid handles on that grill are the exact same as the one that was on the BM that I redid. I have not seen very many that used that style of handle. Maybe they were only used for one or two years.
A few of those "Malts" to get some alcohol flowing through your veins should help to dissolve some of that away. One malt for every breakfast sandwich is generally considered adequate.