• Enter the TVWB 27th Anniversary Prize Drawing for a chance to win a Weber Traveler Portable Gas Grill! Click here to enter!

Two racks of spares


 

PeterD

TVWBB Super Fan
It was a gorgeous sunny 75-degree spring day! Couldn't ask for better conditions for a cook. Two racks of St. Louis cut spares.

PJD_4276-1.jpg


I wanted to try an A/B comparison between racks done with Jane's Butt Rub and BRITU. Both racks were slathered with yellow mustard first. The Jane's rack had a nice application of kosher salt applied first, which I let sit on the meat for a couple of minutes before applying the rub. The BRITU rub went straight on the second rack. These sat in the fridge from midnight until 1:30 this afternoon.

I used the Minion method with 3 chunks of cherry and two chunks of white oak. Cold water used in a foiled water pan. Ribs went on at 2:10pm. At first, temps were hovering around 215 for roughly half an hour. Surprising, but I opened everything up and the temps rose to the mid-230s. I'm using a Maverick ET-73 and only the grate-temp probe, not the meat temp.

As the afternoon wore on, I saw temps spike up to 260 and stay there. I was concerned and closed everything down and the temps held fine in the 250 range after that.

Texas Crutch applied after 3 hours, for 45 minutes. "Probably could have used some more time in the foil," I thought. I kicked the vents full open after the racks were returned to the grate, filled up the water pan with cold water (it was down a little from the start but not much)...and the temps spiked up to 310! This shouldn't be possible.

On a hunch, I found my meat temperature probe, plugged it into the ET-73 and laid it on the grate. It held steady at around 260. Wonderful. Bad grate probe, discovered 4 hours into the cook! Sauce applied nevertheless and left to carmelize for about 45 minutes.

Here are the results:
PJD_4280-1.jpg

CIMG1614.jpg

CIMG1616.jpg

CIMG1617.jpg

CIMG1618.jpg


After the cook as, the temps dropped, the error didn't appear to be linear. As such, I have no clue what temps I was actually cooking the ribs at but I'd estimate low-200s.

The other down side was as soon as the ribs were going nicely I decided to fire up a Cohiba Robusto that I picked up in Toronto last year. It was a plugged dud, I'm afraid to say, and a waste of over $40! The Montecristo #2 made up for it (barely), and the 21 year old Glenfarclas paired nicely. All in all, a Good Day.
 
Even better than they looked! I could have done with leaving the BRITU rack on a tad longer (it was much thicker on one end than the Jane's rack), but still very very good.

I wasn't able to definitively say which rub was better. They were somewhat different but both tasted heavenly. I will not hesitate to use either rub again. I think I was somewhat more partial to Jane's than to BRITU. I was going to do the trimmings in Meathead's Magic Dust but I'd forgotten to make it and just went with a sprinkling of another hotter rub that I'd used last time. Meh at best on that one.
 
Hey Peter - Great job on the spares. It would be hard to find fault with either one of those rubs. Of course don't forget to give credit to the Pitmaster
icon_wink.gif
. Nice looking cook. Bob
wsmsmile8gm.gif
 
Great looking ribs, Peter!

I tried a similar experiment yesterday and did two racks of the Jane's Rub and one rack of the Slap Yo Daddy spares. No water in foiled pan and temp 250-270 for entire cook. I did 3-2-.5 and they were FOTB. Very flavorful, overdone for me, and just what everyone else wanted.

The only adjustment I made to the SYD rub was to substitute 2T of maple sugar for the 2T of brown sugar.

6 Adults sampled both flavors of ribs and only one had a preference of one over the other (SYD preferred). My takeaway is that I'll save the maple sugar for other purposes as it made no appreciable difference on spares.

Ron
 
Can you post a link to the SYD recipe? I wouldn't mind giving it a go at some point (though I think it'll be after I've used up the 3 rubs I already have now).
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by Jim Lampe:
Yeah, Those look AWARD -WINNING! </div></BLOCKQUOTE>

Best compliment I think I've ever received on ribs. Thanks!! Wish I could seriously compete; maybe one of these years, after I perfect my technique and experiment more with rubs and sauces a little!
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by PeterD:
Can you post a link to the SYD recipe? I wouldn't mind giving it a go at some point (though I think it'll be after I've used up the 3 rubs I already have now). </div></BLOCKQUOTE>

The SYD rub recipe is at http://slapyodaddybbq.com/Recipes.html

R
 
Good job having Plan B and Plan C in the wings. I'm sure it was tasty, followed by a good smoke and a nice drink.

Consider stocking your humidor with a CAO MX2 Toro, Rocky Patel 1990, or an Acid Ordinary Larry. All work great with Q. The acid is good for shocking neighbors who come begging for ribs cuz its the size of a bratwurst, (and not really a bad smoke either)

Q-on!
 

 

Back
Top