packer on WSM 18.5 ?


 

Neil Grant

TVWBB Fan
Is it just me or is the above smoker too small for a whole brisket ?

or is there a preferred way to bend or position the beef like perhaps hanging from lid in a net ? Or cut in half ?

Seems to me the above cooker is just too small to lay a packer flat.
 
I've squeezed in 16 pound packers on my 18.5 and they've cooked fine both low and slow and high heat. You just stuff them between the grate handles.
 
If you have a weber roasting rack, put it on the grate upside down and drape the brisket over it, I've gotten 17-18 pound briskets into my WSM that way. Put some foil or fat trimmings under the ends to shield the heat a bit if you can.
 
Most importantly Neil, where did you get the whole packer and how much did you pay/lb? Thanks
 
Jon...'most importantly?' No, that's the easy part.

I'm in Essex County and there's a Western Beef grocery store on the Newark / Orange border. Very large meat deparment and lots of bulk cuts. $2.99 a pound for brisket I believe.

Trouble is, I figured I needed a smallish one to fit on my WSM and at 10 lbs it might not have even had a point...couldn't tell...

they've got 16 + pounders where you can easily see the point but they seem to big for my smoker....so I posted this question to see if there's a way to get the bigger packer on the 18.5

They probably only get 10 or so packers of varying sizes per shipment and they sell fast (restaurants ?) so for more of a selection they tell me it's best to go just after 12:00 on Tue and Thurs, when they get the meat deliveries.

e-mail me at rutgersfan1@hotmail.com if you want me to pick one up for you.
 
As posted by the other users a large brisket fits but you have to arch them. I bought my WSM when only the 18" was available. If I where to cook two briskets regularly I would want a 22" but a single brisket cooks up fine with the 18".

I have never tried to cook a brisket on the lower rack as I fear that the ends would be exposed to too high of a heat when overhanging the water pan.
 
This comes up a lot, and you'll get more opinions if you do some searches. However, as far as smoking just one, as already mentioned, you can squeeze a pretty good size one between the two handles on the top grate. I believe my largest was either a long-ish 14-pounder, or maybe a fifteen pounder, and most of my packers have been smoked like this with pretty good luck. I suggest laying some foil under the end of the flat around where the handle is to help protect the end from the higher temps there.

As for smoking a larger one on the bottom rack, I'd opt for an idea that I found in an older thread. The poster (Keri C.?) suggested cutting a large enough size chunk off the point end to make the brisket fit, laying the chunk beside the brisket. (By the way, Adam Perry Lang suggests doing the same in his new book.) Anyway, Kerry pointed out that since the point has so much more fat to render, it wouldn't overcook before the brisket was tender in the flat, and I've done this before and will confirm that it's a fine option. As on the top grate, I'd lay some foil under the flat end of the brisket where it lays past the edge of the pan, and maybe even the other end, since it's the bottom grate.
 
I do 'em all the time...

DSC00630.JPG
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by Neil Grant:
Jon...'most importantly?' No, that's the easy part.

I'm in Essex County and there's a Western Beef grocery store on the Newark / Orange border. Very large meat deparment and lots of bulk cuts. $2.99 a pound for brisket I believe.

Thanks for the heads up Neil. I went there yesterday (Saturday) and wasn't thrilled with the 1 that was left but bought it anyway. It went into the smoker at 6:30 this morning. With no traffic, Western Beef is only 20 minutes away and worth the trip

Trouble is, I figured I needed a smallish one to fit on my WSM and at 10 lbs it might not have even had a point...couldn't tell...

they've got 16 + pounders where you can easily see the point but they seem to big for my smoker....so I posted this question to see if there's a way to get the bigger packer on the 18.5

They probably only get 10 or so packers of varying sizes per shipment and they sell fast (restaurants ?) so for more of a selection they tell me it's best to go just after 12:00 on Tue and Thurs, when they get the meat deliveries.

e-mail me at rutgersfan1@hotmail.com if you want me to pick one up for you. </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">As for smoking a larger one on the bottom rack, I'd opt for an idea that I found in an older thread. The poster (Keri C.?) suggested cutting a large enough size chunk off the point end to make the brisket fit, laying the chunk beside the brisket. (By the way, Adam Perry Lang suggests doing the same in his new book.) Anyway, Kerry pointed out that since the point has so much more fat to render, it wouldn't overcook before the brisket was tender in the flat, and I've done this before and will confirm that it's a fine option. As on the top grate, I'd lay some foil under the flat end of the brisket where it lays past the edge of the pan, and maybe even the other end, since it's the bottom grate. </div></BLOCKQUOTE>

I'm a big proponent of pretrimming. The top piece in the picture is often much thinner than the rest of the flat and ends up being in the wsm's heat zone. For comps, I want to pretrim so my slices are box width. And I prescribe to a "best use" method to cooking. I buy big packers, trim off the ends that will get overcooked and save them for a better use like ground beef. Every three or so briskets, I get a meal of brisket burgers as a bonus.
IMG_5443.JPG
 

 

Back
Top