I've recently changed the way I cook pork butts, and I'm really happy with it. Basically, instead of cooking that big 7-8 pound hunk of meat whole, I cut or break it apart into 3 or 4 more-or-less equal-sized pieces. I haven't seen this method discussed before... don't know if that's because it's just obvious to everyone but me, or what.
Anyway, the pros of this method are increased bark and reduced cooking time. I originally tried it because I didn't have enough time for my usual overnighter. I found I really liked the extra bark and smoke distribution. I tried it again this weekend with a butt marinated in jerk paste, and it turned out fantastic.
This approach is great when you really want the flavor of the marinade or rub to stand out. And as a bonus, it reduced my cook time from around 20 hours to about 11.
The main drawback of this method is that the cut-up butt takes up more space on the grate. But if you don't need the extra space, it's well worth it.

Anyway, the pros of this method are increased bark and reduced cooking time. I originally tried it because I didn't have enough time for my usual overnighter. I found I really liked the extra bark and smoke distribution. I tried it again this weekend with a butt marinated in jerk paste, and it turned out fantastic.
This approach is great when you really want the flavor of the marinade or rub to stand out. And as a bonus, it reduced my cook time from around 20 hours to about 11.
The main drawback of this method is that the cut-up butt takes up more space on the grate. But if you don't need the extra space, it's well worth it.