So, I picked up some Sweet Baby Rays and some PC Smokin Stampede at my local Loblaws. I did a from the bottle taste test with both.
SBR - Very sweet with a smokey aftertaste. It has "natural smoke flavour" as an ingredient, which I don't know. Also, a little late heat.
PC - Also sweet but with a more fruity acidic flavour, no smoke taste. Note that the PC is advertised as beer and chipotle. I didn't get the chipotle though.
Neither is great out of the bottle but I gave them an even score since the SBR smoke flavour wasn't that appealing and the PC acid (or maybe it was the beer) tasted a little chemically to me.
I then added some pineapple and apple juice, Louisiana Hot Sauce and a pinch of cayenne to both.
The SBR's sweetness evened out a bit but some more acid would have cut it more but the flavour really started to change to fruity.
The PC's sweetness cut pretty well but it became very fruity, almost marmalade like. I still couldn't find the chipotle.
Overall, I chose to use the doctored SBR on some chicken thighs in the oven. I gave them 3 applications. The colour turned out really nice but the flavour really didn't come through. Perhaps I needed to add more.
Now I'm thinking about ditching the doctored commercial sauces and just going with my modified No. 5. I'm doing a few racks of backs Saturday and I'm going with the SBR modified on one rack and my No. 5 on the other to get a better perspective how they react using the WSM and wood smoke.
BTW - I know I'm hijacking my own thread but this doctored commercial vs. homemade has me on the ropes. I read about comp cookers mostly using doctored commercial and winning but I'm still feeling that the bottle sauces taste like the stuff you toss on some grilled porkchops prior to serving. Maybe it's just me