• Enter the TVWB 27th Anniversary Prize Drawing for a chance to win a Weber Traveler Portable Gas Grill! Click here to enter!

First Smoke.


 

Chuck R

TVWBB Fan
Got home from Reno Friday and my new WSM was waiting for me in the box. Put it together and had no problems whatsoever with fit and finish. Middle section fit the lower section like a glove.
Saturday morning, went to Costco but they only had pork shoulder and I wanted to do butts, so off to the butcher’s. Bought two butts, one at 7.42 lbs and the other at 7.26 lbs. Drove over to BBQs Galore to get some apple or cherry chunks but they had no fruitwood whatsoever. I’ll have to make due with a little hickory and some maple.
Got the butts home and trimmed the cap and false cap, 1.06 lbs from one and 1 lb from the other, leaving me with 6.36 lbs and 6.26 pounds trimmed. Slathered them up with French’s yellow mustard then a liberal coating of my own rub. Put them in a pan and covered them with stretch wrap and into the refrigerator. I was going to start them at 7 pm last night but didn’t trust myself for an overnighter for my first smoke, so I let ‘um sit until 3 am this morning. There was about a cup of liquid that leached out from the meat so, if they seem dry when their done, I won’t leave them in the rub overnight.
Took ‘um out and re-rubbed them. The charcoal chamber was filled with BBQ Galore Hardwood Lump, which is supposedly bagged for them by Lazzari in Brisbane (CA). Buried in the lump was a 7 oz chunk of Hickory and two chunks of Maple totaling 11.75 oz. I lit up 25 Kingsford briquettes in the chimney on the side burner on my gasser. They were ready to go in just a few minutes. So I dumped them on the lump and added a 4.5 oz chunk of Hickory and 10 oz of Maple on top of the lit. By the way, as soon as they hit the sump, the sparklers started spitting. Last night I read some OWIE stories here about chefs in shorts and sandals, so this morning I wore sweats and shoes. THANKS FOR THE INFO! I think it definitely saved me from doing a early morning war dance!
I sprayed the grill with Pam, stuck it on the smoker and placed the butts on at 0345. I installed a Maverick ET-73 Ready Check internal meat probe and the grill probe, and put on the lid. All vents were open 100%. Heavy smoke was pouring out of the top vent and from around the bottom of the lid. No smoke was coming from the base or door which showed me that they fit well. Meat temp was 44F and the grill temp. was already up to 266, so I cut the bottom vents to about 33%. By 0405, grill temp. had dropped to 231.
By 0430, the grill temp was at 248 and rising, so I closed two of the bottom vents. I noticed that pictures and videos of the WSM showed the top vent in line with the door, but I had it opposite, so I spun the top around in line with the door without loosing any heat. By 0500, the grill temp. was 233 and slowly dropping. The meat temp. was 94.
0600, grill temp is 223, meat temp is 134. Thin blue wisp of smoke is going straight up from the top vent. Almost no wind whatsoever right now.
I’m taking pictures but wont post them until after the smoke.
If I’m doing anything wrong, or if you have any suggestions for doing it better, please chime in.
Continued.
 
You need to take better notes...you need more detail.


Just kidding. It sounds like you have a pretty good handle on what is going on. No need to rub the meat that far ahead of time though.

Relax and enjoy it!
 
The butts have been on for six hours. At 0730, the meat temp. hit 160 and I anticipated a “stall” while the meat “broke down”, but now (0945) the meat temp is up to 170. I was going to flip the butts and turn them end for end after six hours, but I don’t want to induce an “artificial” plateau by letting the heat out, so I will delay flipping them.

Bill, my motto has always been “If it’s worth doing, it’s worth abusing.” Whenever I’m doing something new, I take copious notes so if something goes wrong, hopefully I have enough info to figure it out. I figure I can never have too much information, and I can cut back in the future if I don’t need it.

I’m REALLY resisting the temptation to take a peek..
 
You don't have to flip or rotate at all. Your choice. Many of us never bother.

Btw, 'butt' is pork shoulder--and is often labeled that way. It's the upper part. 'Picnic' is the upper leg/lower part of the shoulder.

Enjoy your dinner!
 
Kevin, that’s good to know. I probably won’t flip them, I can just imagine how the tops are looking right now, would hate to mess it up. At the butcher’s, I specified the Boston “cut” and not the shoulder or picnic. That is not a “butt”?
 
A 'Boston' butt is pork shoulder, just the upper portion. In most places I travel to butt is called 'pork shoulder' or 'pork shoulder-Boston butt'. I assume your butcher knew that you wanted a 'Boston butt', i.e, the upper shoulder of one side of the hog.

I have not shopped at Costco but I've read here that Costco carries boneless butts (quite possibly labeled 'shoulder', I don't know) exclusively; no bone-in cuts.

(Side note: Many of us don't trim butts at all. Try that approach sometime and see what you think.)
 
Butts have been on for about 14 hours and the meat temperature is at 196. I’m shooting for 200. While I’m waiting, here are some pictures. The first is the untrimmed butts.
Untrimmed2.jpg

This is the trimmed product.
Trimmedbutts.jpg

Butts slathered with yellow mustard.
Mustardbutts.jpg

After the first rub.
Rubbedbutts1.jpg

This is the second rub, after spending the night in the refrigerator.
2ndrub.jpg

Bottom section with lump, lit charcoal and hickory to the left and maple on the right.
Litandchunk.jpg

Closed up and SAMOKIN’.
Smoking2.jpg

I’ll post some pictures of the finished product and the “pull” later. .
 
Lookin good Chuck, you must have a pretty nice kitchen scale
icon_wink.gif
I think the majority of us do not trim/flip/turn or baste for that matter. Butts are pretty much just set and forget. Remember, go by temp for a finish point go by tender. Lookin foreword to more pics!

Brandon
 
The meat hit an internal temperature of 200 right at 8 pm They cooked for a litle over 16 hours. Tried to lift the first one to a cutting board but some bark stuck to the grill and the whole thing fell apart in my hands. I used a spatula to loosen the second butt and moved it to the cutting board pretty much intact. The bones twisted out of both with no meat attached. I double wrapped them in foil and but them in a preheated cooler to rest. The bride and I snuck a taste, REAL good!
Didn’t taste any from the middle, but the med towards the outside seemed a little dry. Maybe it will all moisten up when I pull it.
DONE! Not a great picture. I’ll try to get a better pix when I un-foil them.
Done.jpg

Resting.
Resting.jpg
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by K Kruger:
(Side note: Many of us don't trim butts at all. Try that approach sometime and see what you think.) </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
I Agree with Kevin, don't trim them, no need to. I have never trimmed a butt.
The Butts look great Chuck, nice job on your first cook.
icon_cool.gif
 
Thanks, Bryan. They turned out a little dry. I was afraid of opening the lid early to check it out but I think I’ll do so next time when it hits 190. I’ll also take all of your suggestions and put them on untrimmed. I lost some of the bottom bark sticking to the grill anyway, might as well be fat!

Before the pull
Beforepull.jpg


After the pull
Afterpull.jpg


Pulled Pork for breakfast, MMMmmm.
 
Looks delicious to me!
As for done-ness, screw the temp checking. When you can stick in a fork and twist it with very little if any resistance, you are done. Checking temps will drive you crazy. I've had butts be done at 180 all the way to 205, no rhyme or reason it seems like. The fork test never lies, you can only twist it when they are done. Did four butts fri-night/sat morning, did them high-heat, they were done in exactly 9 hours and were the best ones I've ever done. Couldn't tell you what the temp was, but the fork twisted beautifully!

Taking the leap from temp checking to just checking for done-ness can be stressful, but give it a try and i think you will be happy. It is entirely possible that your butts were "done" sooner, and then dried a little. Also, leave that fat on there, its delicious, and it protects the butts from the heat a little bit.

Either way, your finished product looks very tasty!
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by Mike R.:
Looks delicious to me!
As for done-ness, screw the temp checking. When you can stick in a fork and twist it with very little if any resistance, you are done. Checking temps will drive you crazy. I've had butts be done at 180 all the way to 205, no rhyme or reason it seems like. The fork test never lies, you can only twist it when they are done. Did four butts fri-night/sat morning, did them high-heat, they were done in exactly 9 hours and were the best ones I've ever done. Couldn't tell you what the temp was, but the fork twisted beautifully!

Taking the leap from temp checking to just checking for done-ness can be stressful, but give it a try and i think you will be happy. It is entirely possible that your butts were "done" sooner, and then dried a little. Also, leave that fat on there, its delicious, and it protects the butts from the heat a little bit.

Either way, your finished product looks very tasty! </div></BLOCKQUOTE>

Mike: I notice that you have a "OLD Smokey Electric in your BBQ arsenal. What do you cook on it and is it a good product?

Rick

WSM, OTG 22 1/2" with Smokenator
 
<BLOCKQUOTE class="ip-ubbcode-quote"><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-title">quote:</div><div class="ip-ubbcode-quote-content">Originally posted by Chuck R:
They turned out a little dry. I was afraid of opening the lid early to check it out but I think I’ll do so next time when it hits 190. I’ll also take all of your suggestions and put them on untrimmed. I lost some of the bottom bark sticking to the grill anyway, might as well be fat! </div></BLOCKQUOTE>
Chuck, It's best to go by tender not temp for a doneness. As far as being dry you can use a finishing sauce for you meat. I make a basic one that works quite well IMO. For pork butt I use a 1-1-1 ratio of chicken stock (Knorr boulion cube) butter, and BBQ sauce. For Beef/Brisket change to beef stock. I use 1/4 c for the measure. Yes might as well have the fat cap stick to the grate instead of the meat.
icon_smile.gif
 
I can vouch for Bryan's finisher for brisket, debuted it this weekend to rave reviews. I did a party for about 40 people, and that brisket can dry out real fast when people are filing through the line, so I basted as I sliced, and it was great!

As for my Old Smokey, it was my first smoker. I did some butts on it with decent results. It does fish VERY well. It seals very tight, and the moisture stays inside the unit, so you won't get bark on a butt really. It is a quality product, very simple to use, set it and forget it. I bought mine to get into the smoking game, practice some recipes, and now I use it for fish mostly because it really does a nice job on them. May do some jerky in there too one of these days.
 

 

Back
Top