• Enter the TVWB 27th Anniversary Prize Drawing for a chance to win a Weber Traveler Portable Gas Grill! Click here to enter!

Derby Eve Pork Cook


 

ToddChism

New member
Hello Everyone,

I'm planning on 12-18 hrs. to do 4-12lb. butts on my 22 WSM. Plan on using MM with empty foiled pan. This will be my largest cook to date and need to have finished product by noon on Saturday. Any thoughts or advice would be greatly appreciated!
 
Four 12-lb butts? Those are big.

Timing will depend on cooktemps. At typical low/slow temps you're looking at 20-24 hours inclusive of some resting time. You can shorten the time by raising the temps.

I'd likely do them a day or two in advance, rest, pull, cool, then package for the fridge, reheating for service. Were that not an option I'd likely start them Friday morning.
 
Thanks for the reply Kevin,
Yeah, I'm starting to lean toward an earlier start time but Friday AM? Seriously?

I'd like to have them resting in foil at or around 10 AM. What if I got my temps 250-275 and started @ about 3 PM on Friday?
 
Hey Todd! Here's a couple tips I use to shave hours off the cook time: .. 1) Cut each of the butts in two...more smoke & bark, less cook time
icon_smile.gif
.. 2) Before going to bed, rub 'em & wrap in plastic and leave out ... internal temp will be 60* vs. 40* in the morning when you fire up the WSM
icon_wink.gif
.. Cheers!
wsmsmile8gm.gif
 
Yes, seriously. At typical low/slow temps one can expect 15-18 hours of cooking for butts of typical size, i.e., ~7 or 8 lbs.

You can start later if you bump the cook temp (think closer to 275 than 250); or you can do that and plan on foiling (either late night and stick them in the oven) or in the early a.m. and stick them in the oven or leave in cooker); or, unless needing meat for 80 people, you could do smaller roasts - 4 in the 7- to 8-lb range, started a bit later and cooked 235-250. Or halve them, as ron notes.
 
So for the sake of time and not to mention charcoal, what kind of cook time would I be looking at if I halved those bad boys? Still a lot of mass inside that cooker and I would assume it would stretch beyond the typical 1-1.5 hr per pound.
Thanks for the input!
 
Hey Todd, I did 3 10ish lb butts 2 months ago in my 18.5 WSM with the foiled clay method and lump.

Cooked at 250-260 and they where done in 14.5 hrs.

Not sure it would compare to your 22 and 4 butts, but 3 10 lbrs on the 18 is close.

My 2 cents.
 
If you decide to halve them -

Also be sure to avoid a wimpy fire. That's still a lot of meat.

A decent fire / let it "catch" before putting the meat on will get things off to a good start, which should pay dividends in keeping to your target times. (With butts, it's not as big of a deal if you over-shoot your target temperature at first.)

I'll agree with others on the time opinions - I've had 8-pounderst that took 12 hours. 12-pounders will take SIGNIFICANTLY more time. If you leave 'em big; be sure to err on the conservative time. (Butts that big will stay hot for a LONG time if you foil them & put them in a towel-lined cooler, so if you're done early, no biggie.)
 
Thanks for all the advice guys. Gottem done in 17 hrs. @ 230-250*. Came off the cooker @ 4 AM and beat a torrential downpour by about 5 mins. Now if they will just hold, in the cooler, until noon?
 
Yes, although if you want to serve at noon you'll need to pull the meat first.
icon_smile.gif


Glad it went well.
 

 

Back
Top