Rob Provost
TVWBB Fan
After taking everone's advise (see discussion below - "Cut Butt in half. 3 lbs each, one w/the bone"), I decided to tie the boneless butt just to make sure it wouldn't fall apart. Due to the extra surface area I rubbed them both lightly at 6:00pm with plans of putting them on the smoker first thing in the morning.
Well, I didn't get the Butts on the smoker until 9:30am (of course this is the one day the kids decide to let me sleep late!).
Here's how they looked going on:
Temp held steady all day at around 250 at the lid. At 1:30 I turned and sprayed down with apple juice (I only had enough vinegar left for the sauce). The butts hit 195 at 6:30 and I took them off:
I pulled the Butts, added some extra rub and vinegar sauce, and served with a tomato based sauce. The wife's quote, "This is the best butt yet". I guess the extra bark was the key (or the starvation since I put them on late).
Thanks to all for your advise. I think the benefit of extra bark and decreased cooking time is a win/win. I don't see any negatives to cutting the Butts in half.
Any thoughts?
Well, I didn't get the Butts on the smoker until 9:30am (of course this is the one day the kids decide to let me sleep late!).
Here's how they looked going on:

Temp held steady all day at around 250 at the lid. At 1:30 I turned and sprayed down with apple juice (I only had enough vinegar left for the sauce). The butts hit 195 at 6:30 and I took them off:

I pulled the Butts, added some extra rub and vinegar sauce, and served with a tomato based sauce. The wife's quote, "This is the best butt yet". I guess the extra bark was the key (or the starvation since I put them on late).
Thanks to all for your advise. I think the benefit of extra bark and decreased cooking time is a win/win. I don't see any negatives to cutting the Butts in half.
Any thoughts?