Cooking Brisket High Heat & Disaster!!!


 

Gene_N

TVWBB Fan
My 2nd brisket. I trimmed it down to 12.81 lbs using the modified Louis Charles Henley App-Purpose rub. I was at the 2.5 hr mark with 167 F int temp, lid temp 295 and top rack 304 and prepared to flip, pan and wrap it foil. Unfortunately I could not remove the lid easily and I ended up jarring loose the middle section. The rack slipped into the water pan and crashed cap first into the coals. In the process I trashed my Maverick ET-732 food probe.

After staring stunned for 2 seconds, I dropped the lid, grabbed the brisket with my grill gloves, put it on the pan, fired up my Silver Genesis then went inside and rinsed the entire brisket in hot water. I put it in a new pan and got an instant read temp of 115. I rubbed my hand at point of impact, licked it and got a good taste of ash. I wrapped it in foil, put it in the Genesis then cleaned up my mess.

Gee!!! :mad: I really screwed that one up. What a freaking mess! I wish it could have been filmed, it would have been a YouTube hit :rolleyes:

What more mitigation do I need to do to save this hunk of meat? I'm thinking at the 2.5 hr mark, I will need to re-rinse and re-pan the meat and pitch the juice then cook to finish. I can heat up some beef broth with the rub and use that to baste the meat and use that for burnt ends.

Anything else I should/need to do to the meat? It costs $2.70/lb.

The lid is a tight fit with the middle section. I wipe down the lid lip and middle section groove with a wet paper towel while still hot after every cookd. What can I do to reduce friction?
 
I would think the first rinse was good enough for me at least. Add some broth and re-rub in a clean pan. As far as the lid sticking, wipe it down with vinegar and if it does stick again don't try to force it by lifting it up in a straight motion, add tension on the handle with one hand and using the side of your fist, give it a few love whacks as I like to call em.:wsm:

Tim
 
I re-panned the meat and added 16 oz of beef broth with 2 tbls of the rub. Flat int temp was 198 so another 30 mins should finish the cook. I did not re-rinse the meat. I tasted the contaminated au jus and felt the gritty ash in it. I will separate the cap from the flat then after resting I will remove the gritty bark.
 
Tried checking to see if the lid is out of round? I've got both the 18.5" and 22.5" wsm's and neither lids stick unless there's a lot of grease build-up.
 
Wow, that sucks. At least it's the kind of thing that doesn't happen very often and will make a great story tomorrow...

If you have a stiff bristle brush (I have one I use for cleaning cast iron cookware) maybe give the ash-y end a good scrub ?
 
It was not a complete loss but it's not something I will give my neighbors...

After resting, I scraped away all of the bark, rinsed in hot water then wrapped foil and put in the frig. The cap still has a silty feeling, the two flat sections not so much. After rinsing, the meat looked like corned beef so maybe there is a bit of hope for tomorrow. After I cube the cap tomorrow, add BBQ sauce and cook for another 2 hours it will be servable as burnt ends.

I cooked my first brisket during a day long power outage, the 2nd crashed into the fire. Maybe this is a sign to try spareribs next....
 
I guess every disaster has a silver lining...

I cubed the cap, mixed in a 1/4 cup of apple juice and 2 big dollops of Sweet Baby Ray's BBQ sauce and reheated at 325 F for 90 mins to make KC Burnt Ends. I served it in ramekins to my harshest food critics (my kids, 12, 10 & 8).

SUCCESS!!! The ate it all down and asked for 2nds... The two younger kids prefer milder/sweeter seasonings so I guess the rinsing and de-barking last night contributed to the milder taste.

I may do the same to the 2 chunks of flat that I have remaining...
 
What's a little grit? Think of it as extra minerals, your brisket was vitamin and mineral fortified. You have to find the silver lining in every disaster. I never told my family about dropping a Sirloin Tip on the patio, I just rinsed it off and took it over. What they don't know won't kill them, usually...
 

 

Back
Top