What's odd is I buy all my meat at two local meat markets vs. Costco. Under every circumstance I've been able to find equal (or better) quality for less $$ at these markets over Costco. Also, the one Market I go to will hand carve my steaks for me. We're in Costco at least once every other week, I check the meat prices while there and have yet to purchase a piece of meat there. With this said, I think my situation is very rare. Compared with our local grocery stores the Costco prices are much better.
EDIT: Sorry Chris, I totally misread your post. I don't imagine unless you were buying in very large bulk that you could find a meat distributor willing to sell to an individual. However, being in sales I've always got to be on the optimistic side and always figure "I've got no now, why not ask, what's it going to hurt." So I say what the hell. Also tell the guy you do a lot of smoking and you'd like to drop some off for him sometime. Never hurts to grease the skids.