After reading various threads/posts here and on other forums on smoking on your kettle I finally gave it a try. I bought a 6 pack of fire bricks from ACE and set the OTS up according to the smokenator specs with 48 Kingsford briketts. I also foiled 3/4 of the charcoal grate.
I lit 12 brikets, bit had a really hard time getting such a small amount to light, even with the upside down chimney starter. So i ended up lighting about 25 and then moved only about 15 - 18 into the OtS.
Here is the pork butt. About 3 lbs and a light dusting of Dizzy Dust.
Here the butt is just put on the grate. I used a disposable pie pan with cold water as a heat sink.
Here is the smoking OTS.
I had a hard time for the first couple of hours to control the temp well. the temp int he top of the dome went up to 350. I closed the vents almost completely, but it took quite a bit of time before the temp went down.
Here I took a peak after 3 hours or so.
Shortly after that I finally got a hang of heat control. I got the temp zeroed in at 250.
After the butt had been on for about 3 1/2 hours we had guests come by and we went to the pool for three hours. When i got back the temp was still at exactly 250. I took the temp of the butt, but the way the probe went in and out made it clear the pork was done.
Here are two pics of the pulled results. My wife is usually not a big pork fan, but she ate a good quarter of the butt while I was still pulling it. So the actual yield was higher that it is shown here, but I was just thrilled she liked it as much as she did. I hope the closeup shows the smoke ring well enough. But since these were all snapped quickly with my iPhone, they may not be good enough to show it.
All in all I was happy with the experience and the results. I am sure it is easier with a WSM or a BGE, but for and investment of $20 this is definitely a viable option.


I lit 12 brikets, bit had a really hard time getting such a small amount to light, even with the upside down chimney starter. So i ended up lighting about 25 and then moved only about 15 - 18 into the OtS.

Here is the pork butt. About 3 lbs and a light dusting of Dizzy Dust.

Here the butt is just put on the grate. I used a disposable pie pan with cold water as a heat sink.

Here is the smoking OTS.

I had a hard time for the first couple of hours to control the temp well. the temp int he top of the dome went up to 350. I closed the vents almost completely, but it took quite a bit of time before the temp went down.
Here I took a peak after 3 hours or so.

Shortly after that I finally got a hang of heat control. I got the temp zeroed in at 250.

After the butt had been on for about 3 1/2 hours we had guests come by and we went to the pool for three hours. When i got back the temp was still at exactly 250. I took the temp of the butt, but the way the probe went in and out made it clear the pork was done.

Here are two pics of the pulled results. My wife is usually not a big pork fan, but she ate a good quarter of the butt while I was still pulling it. So the actual yield was higher that it is shown here, but I was just thrilled she liked it as much as she did. I hope the closeup shows the smoke ring well enough. But since these were all snapped quickly with my iPhone, they may not be good enough to show it.


All in all I was happy with the experience and the results. I am sure it is easier with a WSM or a BGE, but for and investment of $20 this is definitely a viable option.