George, I hate to be late to weigh in on this, but I checked mine and it is OK. Only blemish is where I let the lid raise up against a brick retaining wall a year or so ago and there was a scrape on the lid about the size of a pencil eraser. I touched it up with High Temp red paint and it didn't match exactly, but it's close enough that I don't notice it unless the grill is out in the sun.
I, too, am sorry that Weber is jerking you around on this. That isn't the customer service level I've grown used to from Weber. Have you asked to elevate it to a supervisor? What would it take to make you happy? They may not have any replacement red lids in stock since that appears to have been a one year run. Would you be satisfied with a new lid in the "standard" beige color? I think I would try to "elevate" the issue up the ladder.
Tell them they are kinda getting trashed over here on the board because of their non-responsiveness and now some long-time supporters are starting to wonder if the fabled Weber customer service is going the way of the do-do bird........
Good luck - don't give up -
BTW, I decided to buy a replacement burner and regulator for my Q220. Do I need them? No. But if one or the other decides to boink out, I don't want to be "down" while I have to order another set from Weber.
Pat