First cook on the Silver Bandit:
Here are my impressions as a novice. All my previous smoking has been on an ECB, and I've been so frustrated with it that I've only smoked twice in the past 2 1/2 years.
I used the CB for the first time last night. Did a 4 1/2 hour smoke with a couple of slabs of ribs using the
TVWB Basic Baby Back Ribs recipe. I used two chimneys of unlit Kingsford Comp, 1/2 chimney lit, one large chunk of cherry, a big chunk of apple, and a handful of apple chips. I wish I had used 3/4 or a full chimney of lit, because it took a while to come up to temperature. Otherwise, it performed wonderfully, and the only downsides were strictly operator error.
I set it up with the Weber 9815 thermo from my performer in a cork through the lid vent, and my cheap but accurate probe thermo lead squashed under the lid. I also managed to set it up with the handle for the One Touch behind the smoker, but I didn't notice that until it was too late. One more argument for wheels of some sort.
Both vents were wide open until it came up to 250, about 30-45 minutes. When the temp was right, I closed the bottom down to about 10-20%. I adjusted the vents every 30 minutes or so, but that was only because I was seeing how fine my control was. With the frequent adjustments, the temperature stayed dead steady. If you don't mind a 10-15 degree variation, I'm sure you could check it every hour or two. The only smoke leak was right around where my probe lead ran under the lid, which was expected. I'm sure after I find a better way to rig that, it won't leak at all.
Ash buildup was not a concern on this short cook, but it could be on a longer one. I just realized that the ash pan is installed wrong, so hopefully it will be more stable after I fix it.
A few people have asked about goo on the outside, since the lid fits over the barrel, rather than inside on a WSM. Yes, there was a little bit of goo. A small amount dripped off the rim opposite where the probe went under. My theory is that the probe lead put the lid enough out of level to make the goo run down to the opposite side. There were also two small streaks below the corners of the access door. One of these made a goo puddle on the patio about the size of my hand. (I picked up a hot water heater drip pan at HD today to take care of that for the future.)
The temperature was pretty easy to get back under control after I started checking for doneness every half hour. I just put the lid in the slide aside, checked and sprayed the ribs, then put the lid back on and closed all the vents for a few minutes. When the temperature came back down, I opened the top full and the bottom back to 10% or so. After the first time checking, I kept the temp closer to 265 each time. I was hungry.
After I pulled the ribs, I closed down all the vents. When I went back downstairs after dinner (I live in a 3rd floor apartment), the fire was dead out. The amount of charcoal I used was definitely overkill, but I didn't know and didn't want to risk running out of fuel my first time out.
I also posted a
photo gallery with more commentary. I'll do a follow-up gallery with pics of goo, fixed charcoal pan, etc soon.
Mods/Add-ons:
performer thermo through vent
slide aside lid holder
water heater drip pan
To come:
lid-mounted thermo (opinions on tel-tru BQ250?)
Handles from ECB (The bolts are only 1/2" farther apart on center than the CB rivets. I can adjust that)
Some sort of wheeled contraption (maybe some 2x4s and locking casters under the drip pan?)
Eyelets of some sort for my probe