2nd Smoke - 13 lbs of Boston Butt


 

Gene_N

TVWBB Fan
I filled the ring full of Kingsford Competition using the Minion Method, 6L of water, 4 chunks each of cherry and applewood. The meat hit the grill on 0800. I added 2L of water at 1000 and 1200; basted at 1400, 1530 and 1730; then pulled the first butt at 1730 with an internal temps between 189-194F. I flipped the remaining butt but it took another 2.5 hrs to reach 182F, that temp plateau and me checking the int temp and basting drove me nuts. I was getting tired so I pulled it. I had no problems controlling the heat using the lower vents through out the day. I probably added too much water. The WSM is empty but at 200F with 1 lower vent open at 25% 14 hrs later. It's good to know a full ring +1 chimney can go this long.

After resting, I was able to pull 8.5lbs very moist and tender meat with some bark for a 65% yield which is within expected range. I gave a lb each to my grateful neighbors who liked the flavor and moistness. I grazed while pulling but saved the rest in 2 quart ziploc bags for future use.

I used the Steven Raichlen rub and mop recipe for NC style pulled pork. Next time, I won't use so much salt.

Questions:
1. Is there "minimum amount of water that should be maintained? I had no problems maintaining temp but now I have a full bowl of grease water to cleanup.
2. I used boneless butts, they had loose ends which cooked quicker and thus were drier. Would tying the butt up roast style provide a more even smoke?
3. The meat tastes smoked but my palate is not well developed to discern fruit flavors yet. How do you determine "smoke ring penetration"?

Owning a Genesis for the last 10+ yrs, I've gotten spoiled because it's quick with little cleanup but at the expense of the low/slow bbq smoky flavor (I'm a suburban weekend warrior :)). Would smoking for 4-7 hrs then finishing off in the Genesis using 300-350F indirect provide the same flavor(s), moistness and tender meat?
 
Hi Gene, Welcome to the forum, Sounds like your Boston Butt came off with success. Good going.

I personally do not use water in my WSM when I'm smoking Butts. I prefer to use a couple of foil wrapped fire bricks in my foil lined water pan. (Some other members use a clay saucer). My butts come out juicy & tender and the clean up is easy peasy. Check out this section on water pan usage. http://virtualweberbullet.com/waterpanusage.html

I've always tied up my butts for a more even smoke. Also I prefer to leave the bone in. As far as being able to pick up on the different flavors of smoke woods, I think that will come with time and experience. After a few smokes I was able taste different woods used and the amounts used. The smoke ring is clearly visible in smoked meats. It show up as pink on the outer layer of the meat. The amount of smoke ring is determined by various factors. Amount of wood used, cooking & meat temperatures and moisture levels. The smoke ring is formed at the early stages of smoking. After the meat reaches a certain temperature it no longer absorbs the smoke as well.

Finishing off your butt using an alternative cooker is an viable option. See link. http://www.virtualweberbullet.com/pork3.html

Cheers
 
I put about one gallon of water in the pan which I have lined with foil for easy cleaning. As you see water in the pan is a matter of great discussion and personal choice. I have tied butts if they do not seem to be holding a uniform shape. Also I prefer bone in butts. I think it adds flavor and hold the shape better.
Just keep smokin and learning and develop your own per ferried style.

Mike
 
I never use water in my WSM's, just a foiled pan because cleanup is so much easier. Mopping cools the surface of the meat slightly, plus it messes up the rub so I never mop. I'm not sure what you mean by smoke ring penetration, but smoke doesn't penetrate the meat, it accumulates on the surface.
 
You have to try different ways and decide for yourself. I too prefer the bone in and it acts as a heat sink as well. Love it when you can take two fingers, give it a twist and everything lets go and out comes the bare bone. You know your meat is cooked then. I also use a clay saucer but not before I did the water pan method. I use water for ribs only now. I must admit I have not tried a deboned butt however to me it's like a ham vs a cottage roll but that's my preference.
 

 

Back
Top