Sorry I haven't responded earlier. I did pretty much same exact thing. Sounds like the same delicious results. I'm thinking of going with two smaller pizzas next time rather than one bigger one. Thinking it help the crust be a little thicker. Plus, it will be easier to handle. We too had a heck of a time getting the raw dough to the stone. It was basically folded like a calzone by the time we got it off the pan onto the stone. I had to smooth it back out and spread the toppings around again. So, we too will be looking for either a pizza paddle or at least a large spatula.
How did you clean yours? I just used warm water and our kitchen sponge, and tried to get it as clean as I could. I hear it's ok to still have some "burn" marks and stains on it.
We are excited to continue to play around with it. The possibilities seem endless. From breakfast pizzas, to appetizer pizzas, to dessert pizzas! Please keep me updated on any other tips or tricks you learn along the way, or any good pizza ideas. I'll post the same.