Well, from an "American Eats" show on History Channel a few years ago, the "generic all 'American' mainstream bbq sauce" was basically invented by Kraft Foods! It was originally a dry spice packet "Quick Mix 19 Herb Barbecue Sauce Blend" rubberbanded to a bottle of Kraft All Purpose Oil, and free with purchase. And Kraft introduced the first preblended bbq sauce in 1959.
Also on the show Ardie Davis (aka Remus Powers)(who does the Diddy-Wa-Diddy bbq sauce contest at the American Royal in KC) went on to say that quote "eighty percent of the contest cooks will start with Kraft as their base and doctor it up." close quote. !!!!!
I really find this hard to believe myself (
eighty%??!!??), but he is in a position to have first hand knowledge.
Regarding the woods used: on the same show, Lolis Elie, author of "Smokestack Lightning" talks about how every region swears by their wood and product (beef, pork, etc) but really it comes down to what is available around them: Hogs over hickory in the Carolinas and Tennessee; beef over post oak or mesquite in Texas; Mike Mills using apple wood in Murphysboro {Apple City} IL; tri-tip over red oak in California; salmon over alder in the Pacific NW.
I love this quote: "Leave it to Texas to take an unsaleable cut of beef (brisket), cook it over a noxious weed (mesquite), and make them both famous" I read it online somewhere, maybe on TVWB, but don't recall the source.
So it really comes down to making do with what you got or can get cheap or free, whether its the meat, the pit (an open pit originally was just a hole in the ground), the trees that happen to grow in your area, as well as the spices on hand (everyone has salt and pepper and vinegar). Cook it good, and create regional loyalties that everyone will swear by!
Wednesday night June 11, the Travel Channel is showing (check your local listings)
Barbecue Paradise with a lot of fun info, interviews, etc.
The American Eats show is usually reshown on the History Channel around July 4 so watch for it in the next few weeks.
BTW, my props to Cali on the Tri-Tip. Yum. Can't wait to go to The Hitching Post as seen in the movie "Sideways" and also featured on the above Barbecue Paradise show.
Chris: take that Culinary Tour: it is great fun...and fantastically delicious. I hit 7 famous ones on my trip last year, and have several more scheduled for the next few weeks in KC. I can't wait...