It's hard to tell from the 6 hour graph if the dips are low enough to trigger the lid mode or if the dips are a result of the false trigger of the lid mode. You should watch the pit on the 1 hour graph where you see more detail and see if the pit temp is actually 6% below your setpoint? Also, if you disable the ambient temp probe your temperature graph range will rise up from the bottom end and show you better resolution. Another thing you can do is click and drag on the bottom graph over the area in question and the top graph will change to show just that portion (at a higher resolution). Looking at a higher resolution graph are you seeing lid mode trigger before the pit temp dips or after?
That said, 6% of 225F would be 13.5F, so your pit would have to drop to 211.5F before lid mode would be triggered. I don't think the graph shows that happening? If you hover your mouse over any point on the top graph you will get a popup that shows the actual temperature reading for each probe at that spot, does the pit ever report less than 211.5F? If so the HM is working right to trigger lid mode, in that case you may want to raise the Activate setting a bit, 10% would require a dip from 225F to 202.5F before lid mode is triggered.
If the pit doesn't show a dip to 211.5F then your lid mode is being falsely triggered. In this case it could be either a flaky left button, or solder on that button or the resistor attached to it, or I guess on HMV4.3 there could be an issue at the header(s) where the daughter button /LCD board connects to the main HM board.