(Chris, sorry that this is so long. Should this part of the thread be moved to a separate thread?)
Hi Jim,
That's a question I'm beginning to struggle with too. There has been a lot of discussion on the Bread-Bakers lists about various mixers (Bosh, Magic Mill, Dimension 2000, etc.) with none, it seems, being a clear winner:
http://www.bread-bakers.com/
This Yahoo group came my way yesterday and I haven't had a chance to look at it yet, but you might try:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Mixer-Owners/
I have an old KitchenAid 5-quart that was made by Hobart and has been quite faithful, especially considering the workout it has gotten this past year and for the previous book (plug: Maggie Glezer's "Artisan Baking Across America"). Since Hobart doesn't make the KitchenAid anymore, though, I've heard quite a few complaints about the machine (motor burning up). I'd suggest going to your local repair shop and talking to them about their perception of the quality of the machine.
I hope folks here who have the newer KitchenAids will chime in on how satisfied they are with their mixers.
Also, I've seen suggestions to look for a second-hand Hobart-made KitchenAid on Ebay.
Remember, though, that KitchenAid makes several models, some with higher wattages and the latest models with 6-quart bowls.
Of course, a lot depends on what type of mixing you'll be doing - heavy bread doughs or cakes and cookies. And the attachments that are available - pasta maker, sausage stuffer, grain mill (KA's is so-so), meat grinder, etc.
I tried a Kenwood (now Delonghi) for a month or so but found it extremely noisy and the narrow bowl, which helps make it a good mixer, made it difficult to add things and difficult to easily see what is going on with the doughs. But it's a workhorse which can make batch after batch of bread dough and a lot of people like it.
You can see the new Viking and the Electrolux at:
www.kingarthurflour.com (click on the Baker's Catalog and search for "mixer")
Here is one of the messages from last week's bread-bakers list that might be helpful:
------------------------
A good contact is Giselle at MountainTops Milling who is a member of the Yahoo group. She handles both Bosch and Electrolux, but is very helpful without trying to sell you anything. (I have seen lots of complimentary comments about the service she provides.) She gave me a lot of advice when I was trying to decide between a Bosch and the Electrolux. I eventually bought the latter
because it is even more heavy duty than the Bosch and have been very satisfied with it, once I conquered the learning curve.
------------------------------------
Hope this helps. I too would be interested in what others here have to say about mixers.
Rita