I don't see the point in saucing a whole butt before you pull it. I add just a hit of vinegar based sauce after I pull it, then let folks choose to sauce it or not as they see fit when they eat it. Personally I add just a bit more vinegar sauce to mine.
I woudn't even consult with my wife if I had the opportunity to buy a BGE for that price, if one came on sale here I wouldn't even hesitate. I would hit the ATM and be knocking on their door in a matter of minutes! I love my WSM's but there's always room for another BBQ toy.
The way I see it sugar isn't really necesarry for a rub. You could just take some chili powder, a little garlic salt,and black pepper and rub with that.
I don't think that would work very well. Choking down the oxygen on a charcoal fire with a few wood chunks in it is fine.
Choking down a wood fire is not good, it produces a lot of creasote and billowing smoke and will make your meat nasty. Running a stick burner is a PITA. You really need a...
I have about the same exact situation as you Keri, except the roof of my porch is 1x4's, roofed and painted white underneath. I've been smoking like that for at least 2 years. The only thing I won't do is actually leave while I'm running the WSM on the porch, unless it's just to the corner gas...
I have used the briquettes many times in the past and found them to burn similar to old Kingsford. Full ring lasted as long and quite a bit of ash.
They did smell different while burning but I found it to be a pleasant smell.
I've never had that problem with Royal Oak briquettes before. I've used it a lot and it's always lasted about the same amount of time as old Kingsford. It must of been a bad batch or something.
I've used Fab P before and it wasn't too bad. Some people think its the greatest thing since sliced bread. If you go that route I recomend mixing it thinner than the container calls for. You can get it at theingredientstore.com
I think what I was trying to accomplish in the pan was to spread the smokey flavor throughout and get a hint of tang throughout the whole batch. An old pro named Tom Solomon recommends this practice and I do kinda like it.
I have been happy with my Q, just looking to move in new directions...
I've recentley started considering not rubbing my butts/whole shoulders anymore. I have been dedicated to the eastern NC style and I think rubbing my butts is just screwing up the flavor profile I am shooting for. I have been trimming all fat, painting with mustard and then rubbing with rubs...